North Dakota Administrative Code Title 33 - State Department of Health
🔹 Overview: North Dakota Administrative Code (NDAC) Title 33 – State Department of Health
NDAC Title 33 governs the rules and regulations issued by the North Dakota Department of Health (NDDoH). This department is the state’s primary public health agency, responsible for overseeing public health, disease control, sanitation, environmental health, emergency preparedness, and healthcare facility regulation.
Title 33 is one of the most comprehensive titles in the NDAC, encompassing a wide range of health-related regulations that affect individuals, businesses, and public institutions.
🔹 Purpose and Legal Authority
The legal authority for Title 33 is derived from North Dakota Century Code (NDCC) chapters relating to public health and safety. The State Health Officer or the Department of Health is authorized to create rules necessary to implement laws passed by the legislature.
The purpose of Title 33 is to:
Protect and promote public health.
Prevent disease and environmental hazards.
Regulate health facilities and professions.
Establish emergency protocols during outbreaks or disasters.
Ensure public safety through sanitation, water quality, and air quality regulations.
🔹 Structure of Title 33
Title 33 is divided into numerous chapters, each covering a specific area. Some key areas include:
1. Communicable Diseases
Reporting requirements for healthcare providers and labs.
Isolation, quarantine, and treatment procedures.
Vaccination mandates for schoolchildren.
2. Food and Lodging Establishments
Licensing and inspection of restaurants, hotels, and bars.
Sanitation and food handling standards.
Enforcement procedures for violations.
3. Waste Management and Environmental Health
Solid and hazardous waste regulations.
Air and water pollution control.
Public water system standards.
4. Licensing of Health Facilities
Licensing, inspection, and operational standards for:
Hospitals
Nursing homes
Assisted living facilities
Ambulatory surgical centers
5. Emergency Medical Services (EMS)
Licensing of EMTs, paramedics, and ambulance services.
Operational standards for EMS providers.
6. Vital Records
Registration and management of birth, death, and marriage records.
🔹 Key Regulatory Functions
The Department of Health, under Title 33, has authority to:
Enforce compliance through inspections, fines, license suspensions/revocations.
Issue emergency health orders during disease outbreaks or disasters.
Investigate public health complaints.
Administer state health programs, including maternal and child health, HIV/AIDS, and immunization.
🔹 Case Law Involving Title 33
While administrative rules are created and enforced by the Department of Health, their actions and rules can be challenged in court. The main types of case law involving Title 33 relate to:
1. Due Process Challenges to Enforcement Actions
When the Department issues fines, shuts down facilities, or revokes licenses, affected parties often claim their due process rights were violated. Courts examine:
Whether the department followed proper notice and hearing procedures.
Whether its actions were arbitrary, capricious, or unsupported by evidence.
📌 Example (Hypothetical):
A restaurant owner challenges the Department’s decision to close their business due to alleged sanitation violations. The court upholds the closure after finding that inspections were properly conducted, and violations posed a public health risk.
2. Public Health Orders and Individual Rights
During public health emergencies (like disease outbreaks), the Department may issue isolation or quarantine orders. Individuals have challenged these orders on constitutional grounds (liberty, bodily autonomy, etc.).
Courts balance:
The state’s interest in protecting public health.
The individual’s right to freedom and autonomy.
📌 Example (Hypothetical):
An individual placed under quarantine during a tuberculosis outbreak challenges the order as unconstitutional. The court finds the order valid because it was time-limited, evidence-based, and accompanied by due process.
3. Licensing and Regulation of Health Facilities
Health facilities that lose their licenses or are fined may appeal Department decisions. Courts review:
Whether the Department followed proper procedures.
Whether the facility violated specific administrative rules under Title 33.
📌 Example (Hypothetical):
A nursing home appeals a license revocation due to alleged neglect. The court affirms the revocation after reviewing inspection reports and finding that the Department acted within its authority under NDAC 33-07-03.2 (regulation of nursing facilities).
4. Environmental Health and Permitting Disputes
Industrial or municipal entities may challenge Department orders or permitting decisions related to air/water quality, hazardous waste, or sanitation.
Courts evaluate:
Whether the Department followed proper scientific and legal procedures.
Whether the rule or permit condition was reasonable and within statutory limits.
📌 Example (Hypothetical):
A manufacturing plant challenges a fine for illegal emissions. The court upholds the Department’s action because monitoring data and regulations under NDAC 33-15 clearly support the enforcement.
🔹 Legal Principles from Case Law
Some key legal standards used by courts in Title 33-related cases include:
Chevron Deference (state-level equivalent): Courts often defer to the Department’s reasonable interpretation of its own rules unless clearly erroneous.
Substantial Evidence Review: Courts uphold agency decisions if supported by substantial evidence in the administrative record.
Procedural Due Process: Agencies must provide fair notice and an opportunity to be heard before taking action affecting rights or property.
Strict Scrutiny for Liberty Infringements: In cases involving quarantine or forced treatment, courts apply strict scrutiny — requiring a compelling interest and narrowly tailored actions.
🔹 Summary
North Dakota Administrative Code Title 33 establishes the framework for the State Department of Health's operations, covering:
Public health enforcement
Health facility regulation
Environmental protection
Emergency response
Vital records
The Department’s rules affect nearly every North Dakotan — from hospital patients to restaurant patrons — and ensure the integrity of public health systems.
Case law ensures that while the Department has broad authority, it remains accountable through judicial review — especially when actions affect property, business operations, or individual liberty.
RELATED Blog
0 comments