West Virginia Code of State Rules Agency 22 - Forestry
1. Overview of West Virginia CSR, Agency 22 – Forestry
Agency 22 in the West Virginia Code of State Rules governs forestry practices, management, and regulation in the state. Its primary goals are:
Protecting forest resources and wildlife habitat
Regulating timber harvesting and logging operations
Enforcing reforestation and environmental standards
Promoting public safety and fire prevention in forested areas
Implementing statutory mandates under West Virginia Code Chapter 19, Article 1 (Forestry Laws)
Agency 22 is administered by the West Virginia Division of Forestry (WVDOF).
2. Jurisdiction and Scope
Agency 22 applies to:
Private and public forest lands in West Virginia
Logging and timber operations
Forest fire prevention and suppression
Reforestation and sustainable forestry practices
Forest management plans for public lands
Exemptions may include:
Very small timber operations below thresholds set in the rules
Certain state or federal forestry projects where other agencies have authority
Case Law Principle:
Courts have consistently held that Agency 22 regulations are binding on private landowners and operators, provided the activity falls within the statutory definition of forestry operations. For example, logging or land-clearing activities without a permit may be challenged in court if an agency attempts enforcement, but courts generally defer to the agency’s interpretation of forestry rules when it is reasonable and not arbitrary.
3. Key Areas Regulated by Agency 22
A. Timber Harvesting and Logging
Requires permits for commercial logging
Defines harvesting methods and equipment restrictions
Ensures erosion control and waterway protection
Case Law Example:
In disputes over logging violations, West Virginia courts have ruled that operators must comply with harvest permits and erosion control requirements, even if violations are unintentional. Courts often refer to the principle that forestry regulations are preventive and protective rather than punitive.
B. Reforestation Requirements
Operators must replant trees after harvesting
Specifies acceptable species and density
Establishes timelines for reforestation
Case Law Principle:
Courts have upheld penalties for failing to meet reforestation standards. The reasoning is that timely reforestation protects public trust in forest lands, and the state has broad discretion under forestry statutes to enforce these rules.
C. Fire Prevention and Control
Agency 22 mandates fire prevention measures, including clearing firebreaks and reporting fires
Allows WVDOF to enforce penalties for negligence leading to forest fires
Case Law Principle:
Judges have emphasized that fire prevention is a critical state interest. Landowners can be held strictly liable for fire damages if they violate fire control rules, even without intent or negligence.
D. Forest Management Plans
Public lands must have management plans consistent with sustainable forestry
Private owners may adopt voluntary plans to comply with incentives or avoid penalties
Case Law Principle:
Courts respect the agency’s authority to approve or reject forest management plans as long as decisions are based on statutory criteria. Challenges often fail if the WVDOF shows reasonable discretion and follows rulemaking procedures.
4. Enforcement and Penalties
Agency 22 authorizes inspections and site visits
Violations may result in:
Fines
Cease and desist orders
Mandatory corrective actions (e.g., replanting, erosion mitigation)
Case Law Principle:
West Virginia courts have held that enforcement actions must follow due process:
Notice of violation
Opportunity for correction
Right to a hearing if penalties are contested
However, courts typically defer to the agency’s technical expertise in determining violations and required remedies.
5. Procedural Rules
Agency 22 outlines procedural safeguards:
Permit applications and approvals
Recordkeeping and reporting requirements
Appeal processes to challenge agency decisions
Case Law Principle:
If an agency fails to follow its own procedural rules, courts may overturn penalties. For instance, in contested permit denials, courts examine whether the WVDOF considered relevant facts and allowed the landowner to respond.
6. Relationship to Environmental Laws
Agency 22 operates alongside state and federal environmental statutes, including water quality and endangered species protections.
Timber operations must comply with erosion control, wetland, and wildlife protection rules.
Case Law Principle:
Courts have confirmed that forestry rules supplement, not override, environmental statutes. Operators may face dual compliance obligations.
7. Key Themes in West Virginia Case Law
Across multiple decisions, West Virginia courts emphasize:
Agency expertise matters: Courts defer to WVDOF’s technical judgments.
Strict compliance is required: Permits, reforestation, and fire prevention rules are mandatory.
Procedural due process applies: Landowners can contest violations, but must follow administrative rules.
Public interest prevails: Forest protection and fire prevention outweigh individual convenience.
Reasonableness standard: Courts strike down agency actions only if arbitrary, capricious, or outside statutory authority.
8. Practical Takeaways
Any timber operation, logging, or land management activity in West Virginia should first review Agency 22 rules.
Permits and management plans are critical for legal compliance.
Noncompliance can lead to fines, mandatory remediation, or legal action.
Courts will review WVDOF decisions deferentially, giving strong weight to the agency’s expertise.
RELATED Blog
comments