Domestic Violence Legal Remedies
1. Introduction to Domestic Violence
Domestic violence (DV) is any act of physical, emotional, sexual, verbal, or economic abuse by one family member against another. It occurs most commonly between spouses or partners, but can also involve other family members.
Forms of Domestic Violence:
Physical Abuse: Hitting, slapping, burning, or assault
Emotional Abuse: Threats, humiliation, harassment
Sexual Abuse: Marital rape, coercion, or sexual harassment
Economic Abuse: Denying financial support or access to resources
Verbal Abuse: Insults, threats, intimidation
2. Legal Framework in India
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA)
Provides civil remedies including protection orders, residence orders, monetary relief, and custody orders
Defines aggrieved person broadly (wife, daughter, female relative, live-in partner)
Mandates Protection Officers to assist victims
Relevant IPC Sections:
Section 498A: Cruelty by husband or relatives
Section 304B: Dowry death
Section 306: Abetment of suicide
Section 375 & 376: Sexual assault and rape
CrPC Provisions:
Section 125: Maintenance
Section 164: Recording of statements
3. Key Legal Remedies under Domestic Violence Law
Protection Orders – Restrain abuser from harassment or physical harm
Residence Orders – Allow victim to reside in the shared household
Monetary Relief – Compensation for loss, medical expenses, or maintenance
Custody Orders – Grant temporary custody of children to the aggrieved
Police and Judicial Assistance – Enforcement of orders, protection from repeated abuse
4. Landmark Case Laws on Domestic Violence Remedies
Case 1: Indra Sarma v. V.K. V. Sarma (2013) – Live-in Relationship Rights
Facts:
A woman in a long-term live-in relationship sought protection and maintenance after harassment.
Judgment:
Supreme Court recognized that live-in partners could claim protection and maintenance if the relationship was of long duration and stable nature.
Significance:
Expanded domestic violence protection beyond legally wedded spouses.
Case 2: D. Velusamy v. D. Patchaiammal (2010) – Live-in Partner Protection
Facts:
Aggrieved woman in a live-in relationship faced harassment.
Judgment:
Court held that long-term cohabiting relationships qualify for protection under PWDVA.
Remedies included residence, protection, and maintenance orders.
Significance:
Strengthened legal recognition of live-in partners’ rights against domestic abuse.
Case 3: S. R. Batra v. Taruna Batra (2007) – Maintenance during Divorce
Facts:
Woman sought interim maintenance during divorce proceedings citing cruelty.
Judgment:
Supreme Court upheld her right to interim maintenance based on evidence of physical and mental abuse.
Significance:
Reinforced that civil remedies like maintenance are available even during divorce proceedings.
Case 4: Preeti Gupta v. State of NCT Delhi (2012) – Enforcement of Protection Orders
Facts:
Husband continued to harass victim despite court protection orders.
Judgment:
Delhi High Court enforced protection orders, restraining husband from contacting the victim.
Significance:
Highlighted the practical utility of PWDVA in ensuring immediate safety.
Case 5: Bharati v. State of Gujarat (2009) – Dowry Death and Cruelty
Facts:
Victim subjected to harassment and dowry demands resulting in death.
Judgment:
Gujarat High Court emphasized strict enforcement of Section 304B and PWDVA protections.
Significance:
Showed that criminal and civil remedies work together to address domestic violence.
Case 6: Sheela Barse v. Union of India (1986) – Institutional Protection
Facts:
Women in shelters and protective homes faced abuse.
Judgment:
Court directed protection, legal aid, and monitoring of vulnerable women, recognizing the State’s duty.
Significance:
Established that domestic violence protection includes institutional safeguards.
5. Principles from Case Law
Live-in partners are protected under domestic violence laws if relationship criteria are met
Protection orders are enforceable with police assistance
Maintenance and monetary relief are key civil remedies
Evidence includes complaints, medical records, witnesses, and prior abuse history
Criminal and civil remedies often work together for effective protection
6. Conclusion
Domestic violence legal remedies in India include protection, residence, maintenance, custody, and police enforcement.
Landmark cases such as Indra Sarma, D. Velusamy, S.R. Batra, Preeti Gupta, and Bharati v. Gujarat highlight how courts implement these remedies.
Effective protection requires prompt enforcement, legal awareness, and integration of civil and criminal remedies.
RELATED Blog
0 comments