Child Rights And Juvenile Justice Reforms In Afghanistan
I. Introduction
Afghanistan’s children have historically faced significant challenges due to conflict, poverty, and weak legal protections. However, in recent years, the Afghan government, with international support, has introduced important reforms aimed at protecting child rights and improving the juvenile justice system.
II. Legal Framework
1. Afghan Constitution (2004)
Article 44: Protects children’s rights, obliging the state to provide care, education, and protection.
Article 54: Protects children against exploitation and abuse.
2. The Elimination of Violence Against Children (EVAC) Law (2017)
Comprehensive law aiming to protect children from violence, abuse, neglect, and exploitation.
Establishes protection mechanisms, reporting systems, and legal penalties.
3. Juvenile Justice Law (2005, revised in 2016)
Governs treatment of children under 18 who are accused or convicted of crimes.
Emphasizes rehabilitation over punishment.
Provides for specialized juvenile courts, separate detention facilities, and alternatives to detention.
4. International Treaties
Afghanistan is party to the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC, 1994).
Obligated to protect child rights in accordance with international standards.
III. Core Principles of Child Rights and Juvenile Justice in Afghanistan
Best interests of the child must be the primary consideration.
Non-discrimination and equal protection under the law.
Right to survival and development including education and health.
Protection from violence, abuse, and exploitation.
Special treatment in justice system: Rehabilitation, education, protection from adult offenders, legal representation.
IV. Case Law and Practical Examples
Below are five detailed cases illustrating challenges, reforms, and progress in child rights and juvenile justice in Afghanistan.
1. The Case of Ahmad (2013) – Child Detention and Rights Violation
Background: Ahmad, a 14-year-old, was arrested for petty theft and detained alongside adults in a Kabul prison.
Legal Issues: Violated Juvenile Justice Law’s mandate for separation from adults; deprived Ahmad of education and legal representation.
Outcome: Afghan Independent Human Rights Commission (AIHRC) intervened, resulting in Ahmad’s transfer to a juvenile rehabilitation center.
Significance: Highlighted systemic challenges in enforcing juvenile justice law and the importance of monitoring mechanisms.
2. The Case of Mariam (2015) – Child Marriage and Domestic Violence
Background: Mariam, 16, was forcibly married and subjected to domestic violence.
Legal Issues: Violations of Article 44 (child protection) and the EVAC Law.
Response: Local NGOs and AIHRC provided legal aid; Mariam’s forced marriage was annulled.
Judicial Outcome: Perpetrators were prosecuted under the EVAC Law.
Significance: Demonstrated emerging legal recognition of child marriage as a violation of child rights and the capacity of Afghan law to intervene.
3. The Juvenile Rehabilitation Program in Herat (2017)
Background: Herat’s juvenile justice system implemented reforms introducing education and psychological counseling for children in conflict with the law.
Program Features: Alternative sentencing, vocational training, and reintegration programs.
Outcomes: Significant reduction in recidivism rates among juvenile offenders.
Legal Context: Supported by Juvenile Justice Law and international donor funding.
Significance: Case exemplifies positive reform efforts and the potential of the Afghan juvenile justice system to prioritize rehabilitation.
4. The Case of Zaman (2018) – Child Soldier Recruitment
Background: Zaman, 15, was recruited by an armed group and later detained for possession of weapons.
Legal Issues: Child recruitment violates international and Afghan law.
Legal Proceedings: Afghan courts treated Zaman as a victim, not a criminal, and placed him in a protective care program.
Significance: Important precedent emphasizing rehabilitation over punishment for child soldiers; aligned with Afghanistan’s commitments under international humanitarian law.
5. The AIHRC Report on Child Detention Conditions (2019)
Findings: AIHRC documented overcrowding, lack of education, and poor conditions in juvenile detention centers across Afghanistan.
Recommendations: Urged government reforms including improved facilities, training for officials, and legal reforms.
Impact: Prompted Ministry of Justice to allocate funds for juvenile detention reforms.
Significance: Highlights ongoing challenges in implementation despite legal frameworks.
V. Challenges to Child Rights and Juvenile Justice in Afghanistan
Security situation: Conflict exposes children to violence and recruitment.
Cultural practices: Child marriage, corporal punishment remain prevalent.
Weak enforcement: Lack of trained personnel, inadequate infrastructure.
Limited awareness: Among judiciary, police, and communities about child rights.
Resource constraints: Hinder reforms and proper rehabilitation programs.
VI. Conclusion
Afghanistan has made important legislative and policy strides in protecting child rights and reforming juvenile justice. The legal framework aligns with international standards emphasizing protection, rehabilitation, and non-discrimination. However, practical challenges remain significant, particularly in enforcement and implementation due to conflict, resource shortages, and social norms.
Continued commitment to:
Capacity building for law enforcement and judiciary,
Investment in juvenile facilities,
Community awareness campaigns, and
Strengthening legal protections
are essential to safeguarding the rights of Afghan children and ensuring fair juvenile justice.
RELATED Blog
0 comments