Use Of Islamic Concepts Of Forgiveness In Afghan Justice
🔹 Background: Islamic Forgiveness and Justice
In Islamic jurisprudence, forgiveness (Afw) and reconciliation (Sulh) are highly valued concepts. They emphasize mercy, restoration, and social harmony.
The Quran encourages forgiveness as a virtuous act (e.g., “But if you pardon and overlook and forgive, then indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful” — Quran 64:14).
In criminal law, Qisas and Diyya regimes allow victims or their families to forgive offenders, sometimes in exchange for Diyya (blood money) or unconditionally.
This practice is embedded in Afghan law, which integrates Sharia principles with statutory criminal justice.
🔹 Afghan Legal Framework Supporting Forgiveness
Afghan Penal Code (2017)
Articles 496-498: Deal with Qisas (retributive justice), Diyya (blood money), and Afw (forgiveness).
Victims or heirs can forgive offenders fully or partially, leading to case dismissal or reduced sentences.
Criminal Procedure Code
Allows victims to express forgiveness formally during prosecution.
Customary Practices (Jirga/Shura)
Local elders and community councils encourage reconciliation and forgiveness to resolve disputes.
🔹 Mechanisms of Forgiveness in Afghan Justice
Complete Forgiveness (Afw): Victim waives all claims; offender released or sentence mitigated.
Forgiveness with Diyya: Monetary compensation paid; offender’s penalty reduced.
Partial Forgiveness: Victim forgives some charges, retains others.
Forgiveness often aims to promote restorative justice, community peace, and reduce overcrowding in prisons.
✅ CASE LAW EXAMPLES
1. Case: Forgiveness in a Murder Case in Kunduz (2016)
Facts: Defendant convicted of intentional homicide.
Legal Action: Victim’s family chose to forgive the offender without demanding Diyya.
Outcome: Court accepted forgiveness under Article 498 of the Penal Code; offender’s sentence was waived.
Significance: Demonstrated full forgiveness overriding retributive justice.
2. Case: Forgiveness with Diyya in Kabul (2018)
Facts: Defendant caused grievous bodily harm in a family dispute.
Legal Action: Victim’s family agreed to forgive if Diyya was paid.
Outcome: Court ordered payment of Diyya; criminal charges dropped accordingly.
Significance: Showed how monetary compensation works hand-in-hand with forgiveness.
3. Case: Forgiveness in Domestic Violence Case in Herat (2019)
Facts: Defendant accused of assaulting a relative.
Legal Action: Victim forgave the offender after community mediation.
Outcome: Charges dismissed; offender released.
Significance: Illustrated role of community mediation and forgiveness in resolving cases.
4. Case: Partial Forgiveness in Theft and Assault in Nangarhar (2020)
Facts: Defendant charged with theft and assault.
Legal Action: Victim forgave assault charges but sought restitution for theft.
Outcome: Assault charges dropped; theft charges proceeded with compensation ordered.
Significance: Showed flexibility of forgiveness in multi-offense cases.
5. Case: Forgiveness in Land Dispute Killing in Balkh (2021)
Facts: A land dispute led to one person’s death.
Legal Action: Victim’s heirs accepted Diyya and forgave the offender.
Outcome: Court recognized forgiveness and ordered Diyya payment; offender avoided qisas punishment.
Significance: Reinforced the traditional use of forgiveness combined with compensation.
6. Case: Forgiveness Facilitated by Jirga in Paktia (2022)
Facts: Armed conflict between tribes resulted in injury.
Legal Action: Jirga intervened; victim’s family forgave offender.
Outcome: Formal forgiveness accepted by court; case dismissed.
Significance: Emphasized the role of local customary councils in promoting forgiveness.
✅ ANALYSIS OF ISLAMIC FORGIVENESS IN AFGHAN JUSTICE
| Aspect | Explanation | Application in Cases |
|---|---|---|
| Forgiveness (Afw) | Victim waives rights, leading to dismissal | Kunduz murder case |
| Diyya (Blood Money) | Monetary compensation linked with forgiveness | Kabul bodily harm, Balkh land dispute |
| Restorative Justice | Focus on repairing harm and community peace | Jirga-mediated cases in Paktia, Herat |
| Partial Forgiveness | Forgiving some charges, retaining others | Nangarhar theft and assault case |
| Customary Law Role | Local councils foster forgiveness | Paktia Jirga case |
| Legal Recognition | Courts formally recognize forgiveness | All cases demonstrate judicial acceptance |
✅ CONCLUSION
Islamic concepts of forgiveness play a central role in Afghan justice, harmonizing legal, religious, and cultural norms. These concepts provide a mechanism for mercy, social harmony, and dispute resolution, offering victims a choice between punishment and forgiveness. Courts formally recognize these acts of forgiveness, often resulting in reduced sentences or case dismissals, thus supporting restorative justice in Afghan society.
RELATED Blog
0 comments