Penology in United Arab Emirates
Penology in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) is characterized by a mix of traditional punitive approaches and efforts to modernize the penal system in line with international human rights standards. The UAE’s penal system is shaped by Islamic law (Sharia), local traditions, and the country's rapid modernization. There are significant differences in the criminal justice and penal approaches between the UAE and Western countries, with an emphasis on law and order, deterrence, and a punitive approach to criminality. However, in recent years, there have been some efforts to incorporate rehabilitation and reforms into the system.
Here is an overview of penology in the UAE:
1. Historical and Legal Context
Sharia and Secular Law: The UAE's legal system combines Islamic law (Sharia) with secular laws. Sharia heavily influences penal codes, particularly for crimes such as theft, adultery, and alcohol-related offenses. However, the UAE also follows civil law principles in its criminal justice system, especially for commercial crimes and non-religious offenses.
Penal Code: The UAE Penal Code outlines various criminal offenses and penalties, including prison terms, fines, and corporal punishment for specific crimes (e.g., flogging for alcohol consumption or drug trafficking). However, some punishments, such as public executions, are not practiced in modern UAE.
2. Prison System and Conditions
Modern Prisons: UAE prisons are generally modern in terms of infrastructure and security. The government has invested in building new prison facilities with high standards of surveillance and safety. However, there are concerns about the quality of life in prisons, particularly regarding overcrowding, mental health care, and rehabilitation programs.
Overcrowding: While not as severe as in some other countries, overcrowding is still an issue in some UAE prisons due to the rapid increase in the prison population, especially in relation to non-violent offenders and migrant workers.
Prisoner Treatment and Human Rights: The treatment of prisoners has drawn attention from human rights organizations. There have been reports of torture, inadequate living conditions, and long pre-trial detentions. Some prisoners, particularly foreign nationals and political prisoners, have faced harsh treatment or mistreatment.
3. Punishments and Sentencing
Harsh Sentencing for Specific Crimes: The UAE is known for its strict approach to crime, particularly in relation to drug trafficking, theft, and moral offenses such as adultery, alcohol consumption (for non-Muslims), and homosexuality, all of which are punishable under Sharia law in certain circumstances.
Death Penalty: The death penalty is still retained for specific serious crimes such as murder, terrorism, and drug trafficking. However, the UAE has a relatively low number of executions each year, and in many cases, the death sentence can be commuted to life imprisonment or a lengthy prison term.
Corporal Punishment: The UAE's penal system includes corporal punishment for certain offenses, such as flogging for alcohol consumption by Muslims, though these punishments are typically applied in a limited manner. The government occasionally uses corporal punishment for crimes like blasphemy or drug-related offenses, though it is not frequently practiced.
Sentences for Foreign Nationals: Many prisoners in the UAE are foreign nationals, particularly migrant workers. They can face long sentences, and the system has been criticized for discriminating against foreign workers in terms of the length and type of punishment they receive.
4. Rehabilitation and Reintegration
Rehabilitation Programs: Rehabilitation is not a primary focus of the UAE penal system, and while the government has made some efforts to improve prisoner rehabilitation, these programs are limited in comparison to those in Western countries. Educational programs, vocational training, and job skills are available in certain prisons, but they are not as widespread or comprehensive as needed to facilitate effective reintegration.
Social Reintegration: The UAE penal system focuses more on deterrence than on reintegration. However, for those prisoners who are released, social reintegration efforts include providing job training, housing support, and counseling in some cases. The government has also launched some initiatives to reduce recidivism by offering alternative sentences for non-violent offenders.
Religious Programs: Given the significant role of Islam in the UAE’s culture and penal system, many prisons offer religious programs to inmates, including Quranic studies and prayers. These programs aim to instill moral values and guide inmates back to a "right path."
5. Alternatives to Incarceration
Alternative Sentences: The UAE is working on expanding alternatives to incarceration for non-violent offenders, particularly for minor crimes. Probation, house arrest, community service, and fines are some of the alternatives used, particularly for expatriates or those convicted of non-violent offenses.
Mediation and Reconciliation: In some cases, the UAE encourages mediation between victims and offenders, particularly in civil disputes or cases of minor criminal offenses. This approach is part of the growing interest in restorative justice, though it is not widely implemented.
6. Juvenile Justice
Special Juvenile Courts: The UAE has a separate judicial system for juveniles, which includes courts specifically dedicated to young offenders. The aim is to provide more rehabilitative measures for juveniles, emphasizing education, social reintegration, and family support.
Rehabilitation for Juveniles: The juvenile justice system in the UAE focuses on providing rehabilitation to minors, with specific programs tailored to their psychological and social needs. However, there are concerns about the adequacy and availability of these programs across all facilities.
7. Human Rights and International Criticism
Human Rights Concerns: Human rights organizations, including Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, have repeatedly raised concerns about the UAE's penal system. Issues include:
Arbitrary detention and lack of due process.
Torture and ill-treatment of prisoners.
Harsh treatment of political prisoners, journalists, and activists.
Unfair trials and lack of access to legal representation, particularly for those accused of political or sensitive crimes.
International Attention: The UAE's penal system has come under scrutiny by international human rights bodies due to reports of human rights abuses in detention, limited freedoms of expression and assembly, and the repression of political dissent. However, the UAE government defends its penal policies as being necessary to maintain national security and public order.
8. Recent Developments and Reforms
Penal Reforms: The UAE has made some efforts to modernize its penal system. Notably, in 2021, the country introduced a significant criminal justice reform package, which included changes in areas such as:
Reducing sentences for some non-violent crimes.
Expanding the use of electronic monitoring devices (e.g., ankle bracelets) to manage offenders without incarceration.
The potential reduction of punishments for certain moral offenses, such as alcohol consumption and cohabitation.
Human Rights Commitments: The UAE has indicated a willingness to improve its human rights record as part of its broader efforts to modernize the country’s image and meet international standards, including aligning more closely with the UN's Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Conclusion
Penology in the UAE is characterized by a combination of traditional Islamic legal principles and modern, state-controlled penal practices. The country's approach to criminal justice has been criticized for being overly punitive and harsh, particularly for moral and drug-related offenses. While there are some efforts toward reform, including initiatives for rehabilitation and alternatives to imprisonment, the system remains more focused on deterrence and punishment than rehabilitation. The UAE's penal system is under scrutiny for its human rights practices, with international human rights organizations calling for more significant reforms to align with global standards. However, the UAE has made strides in some areas of legal reform and may continue to evolve its approach to punishment and rehabilitation.
RELATED Blog
0 comments