Lawyers In Criminal Court Absolute Necessity, Not Luxury: Delhi HC
Principle: Legal Representation in Criminal Trials is a Necessity, Not a Luxury
The Delhi High Court has emphasized that legal aid and representation are not privileges or optional benefits, but fundamental rights, especially in criminal proceedings. A person accused of a crime faces the might of the State, and to ensure a fair trial, legal assistance is essential — not a matter of personal wealth or status.
⚖️ Constitutional and Statutory Framework
1. Article 21 – Right to Life and Personal Liberty
Guarantees the right to a fair trial, which includes the right to legal representation.
A trial without proper legal assistance is not considered "fair" under Article 21.
2. Article 22(1) – Right to Counsel
States that no person who is arrested shall be denied the right to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner of their choice.
3. Section 303 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC)
Guarantees that every person accused of an offence before a criminal court has the right to be defended by a pleader of their choice.
4. Section 304 CrPC
Mandates free legal aid for indigent accused persons, ensuring that lack of money does not mean lack of justice.
📜 Delhi High Court's Observations
In a recent judgment, the Delhi High Court observed:
“The presence of a competent lawyer is not a luxury in criminal proceedings; it is a legal and constitutional necessity. An accused cannot be expected to defend themselves effectively against serious charges without proper legal assistance.”
The Court further noted:
The adversarial criminal justice system assumes both sides have legal assistance.
The imbalance of power between the State and an individual demands that the latter be properly represented.
Failure to provide effective legal representation violates the right to fair trial.
🧾 Supporting Supreme Court Judgments
1. Hussainara Khatoon v. State of Bihar (1979)
The Supreme Court held that legal aid is a fundamental right under Article 21.
The Court noted that no trial can be fair unless the accused is properly defended, especially when the person is poor or illiterate.
2. Khatri (II) v. State of Bihar (1981)
It was held that legal aid must be provided at the time of first appearance before the Magistrate, and not just at the trial stage.
The Court stated: “Right to legal aid is a fundamental right of the accused, not a matter of charity.”
3. Mohd. Hussain v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) (2012)
The Supreme Court set aside a conviction because the accused did not have proper legal representation.
It emphasized that absence of legal counsel seriously prejudices the defence and vitiates the trial.
4. Anokhilal v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2020)
The Supreme Court declared that denial of proper legal representation is not a curable irregularity — it renders the trial void ab initio.
It stated that "the right to a lawyer is not a formality — it is a critical guarantee."
🧠 Why Legal Representation is Crucial in Criminal Cases
Complexity of Law
Criminal law involves procedural and evidentiary complexities that a layperson cannot handle alone.
Protection Against Miscarriage of Justice
Lawyers play a vital role in cross-examination, legal strategy, and raising constitutional objections.
Balancing the Scales
The prosecution is backed by the State. To ensure fairness, the accused must have equal legal standing.
Safeguarding Rights
Lawyers ensure that the rights of the accused are not violated during arrest, investigation, or trial.
⚖️ Practical Application
Courts must ensure that no trial proceeds without ensuring the accused has access to legal counsel.
Legal aid authorities must be proactive in assigning lawyers when the accused cannot afford one.
Trials conducted without legal representation can be set aside as invalid.
✅ Conclusion
The Delhi High Court rightly held that legal representation in criminal courts is an absolute necessity, not a luxury. This principle is backed by the Constitution, CrPC, and decades of Supreme Court jurisprudence. A fair criminal justice system cannot exist unless every accused is given a real opportunity to defend themselves through competent legal counsel.
RELATED Blog
0 comments