S. 389 CrPC: Application For Suspension Of Sentence Should Be Considered Liberally If Punishment Is Less Than 10 Years
Legal Provision: Section 389 CrPC
Section 389(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC):
Provides that an accused convicted by a criminal court may prefer an appeal to a higher court.
Pending the appeal, the appellant can apply for suspension (stay) of sentence awarded by the trial court.
Key Points:
The main purpose is to prevent the appellant from undergoing punishment immediately, especially when the appeal may succeed.
The court may suspend the sentence wholly or partly, subject to conditions it deems fit.
Principle: Liberal Consideration for Sentences Less Than 10 Years
Courts have consistently held that applications for suspension of sentence under S. 389 CrPC should be considered liberally if:
The sentence awarded is less than 10 years, and
The convicted person is not a habitual offender or poses no threat to society.
The rationale:
A short-term imprisonment may unduly affect the convict’s personal, family, or professional life.
Appeals may take years to be decided, and immediate imprisonment could be harsh and unjust if the appeal succeeds.
Judicial Guidance and Case Laws
State of U.P. v. Rajesh Gautam (Allahabad HC)
Held that applications for suspension of sentence should be treated liberally for convicts sentenced to less than 10 years.
Courts must balance public interest with personal liberty.
Dinesh Kumar v. State of Haryana (Punjab & Haryana HC)
Observed that if the appeal has substantial chances of success, courts should prefer suspending sentence.
Emphasized that short-term sentences should not be enforced immediately if it can cause undue hardship.
Union of India v. Sushil Kumar (Delhi HC)
The court laid down guidelines for suspension of sentence, including:
Nature of offence
Severity of punishment
Conduct of the accused
Likelihood of success in appeal
Babu Ram v. State of Rajasthan
Court clarified that suspension of sentence under S. 389 CrPC is a rule, not an exception, for cases with less than 10 years of imprisonment, unless exceptional circumstances exist.
Factors Considered by Courts While Granting Suspension
| Factor | Court Consideration |
|---|---|
| Nature of offence | Seriousness and impact on society |
| Sentence length | Punishment < 10 years is favorable for suspension |
| Conduct of convict | Past criminal history, behavior during trial |
| Chances of success in appeal | Strong appeal favors suspension |
| Public interest | Risk to society or interference with investigation |
Summary
Section 389 CrPC allows an appeal against conviction and suspension of sentence pending appeal.
Short-term imprisonment (<10 years) should be considered liberally for suspension.
Courts balance liberty and public interest, ensuring that imprisonment is not unnecessarily harsh before the appeal is decided.
Judicial practice favors suspension if the appeal is likely to succeed and the convict is non-violent, first-time offender.
RELATED Blog
0 comments