Chargesheets Submitted By Police Officers Must Have All Necessary Details As Per Section 173(2) CrPC: SC
The requirement that chargesheets submitted by police officers must have all necessary details as per Section 173(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), along with relevant case laws,
Section 173(2) CrPC: Overview
Section 173 of the CrPC deals with the report of the police officer after investigation. Specifically, Section 173(2) states:
"The report submitted under subsection (1) shall contain a police officer's opinion as to whether or not there is sufficient evidence to justify the framing of charges and, if so, a statement of the charge which, in his opinion, ought to be framed."
This means that after the investigation, the police officer must submit a chargesheet (also called a final report) which:
Summarizes the facts found during the investigation.
Contains all relevant evidence collected.
Expresses the opinion of the police about whether charges should be framed.
Specifies the precise charges proposed.
Importance of Complete and Detailed Chargesheet
The chargesheet is a critical document because it forms the foundation for the trial. An incomplete or vague chargesheet can cause:
Delay in trial,
Violation of the accused's right to know the case against them,
Prejudice in the fair trial process,
Possible quashing of the charges by the court.
Thus, courts have repeatedly emphasized that the chargesheet must be complete, detailed, and comply with the mandate of Section 173(2).
Key Components Required in Chargesheet Under Section 173(2)
Summary of investigation: Including how evidence was gathered.
List of witnesses: Along with statements or summaries.
Details of offences: Exact charges proposed, linking evidence to the offences.
Opinion on sufficiency of evidence: Whether there is prima facie case.
Documents and exhibits: All relevant material gathered.
Judicial Pronouncements on Chargesheet Requirements
1. State of Punjab v. Baldev Singh, (1999) 3 SCC 666
Key point: The Supreme Court held that a chargesheet must clearly specify the charges proposed, and must disclose a clear opinion about the sufficiency of evidence.
It cannot be a mere formal or mechanical exercise. A vague or incomplete chargesheet would be liable to rejection.
2. Bhajan Lal v. State of Haryana, AIR 1992 SC 604
This landmark judgment highlighted the importance of the police report (chargesheet) in the criminal justice system.
Though not directly about 173(2), the Court clarified the need for reasonable material and factual basis before framing charges.
The chargesheet must be based on proper investigation and not be a mere formality.
3. Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal, (2014) 8 SCC 682
The Court emphasized that the chargesheet is an important document that contains the fruits of investigation.
It should contain all relevant facts and evidence enabling the court to proceed with framing charges.
A vague or incomplete chargesheet would amount to miscarriage of justice.
4. Nandini Satpathy v. P.L. Dani, AIR 1978 SC 1025
The Court explained the accused’s right to know the case against him.
The chargesheet should not leave the accused guessing about the allegations or evidence.
5. Gurbachan Singh v. State of Haryana, AIR 1997 SC 270
It was held that the police must submit a comprehensive chargesheet with all necessary details and cannot submit an incomplete report.
The chargesheet should guide the court on whether charges ought to be framed.
Practical Implications
Investigating officers must ensure the chargesheet is thorough and complete.
The Prosecution relies on the chargesheet to decide charges and frame the case.
The Court examines the chargesheet to decide whether to frame charges.
The Accused must receive a clear chargesheet to prepare an effective defense.
Summary
| Aspect | Requirement as per Section 173(2) CrPC |
|---|---|
| Opinion | Must state if evidence is sufficient to frame charges |
| Charge Statement | Must clearly specify proposed charges |
| Completeness | Must include all relevant facts, evidence, and witness details |
| Legal Effect | Forms basis for court’s framing of charges and trial initiation |
| Judicial View | Chargesheet must be clear, detailed, not vague or incomplete |
RELATED Blog
0 comments