Difference Lies In The Degree Of The Act: SC Explains Subtle Distinction Between Culpable Homicide U/s 304 IPC...
Difference Lies in the Degree of the Act: SC Explains Subtle Distinction Between Culpable Homicide U/s 304 IPC
1. Understanding Culpable Homicide Under Section 304 IPC
Section 304 IPC deals with culpable homicide not amounting to murder. This section recognizes that not all killings are murder, and there is a gradation based on the degree of intention, knowledge, and circumstances.
Section 304 IPC is divided into two parts:
Section 304 Part I: Culpable homicide by doing an act with the intention of causing death, or with the intention of causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause death.
Section 304 Part II: Culpable homicide by doing an act with knowledge that it is likely to cause death but without any intention to cause death or bodily injury likely to cause death.
2. Difference Between Section 302 and Section 304 IPC
Section 302 IPC deals with Murder, which requires intention or knowledge that the act is so imminently dangerous that it must result in death or cause such bodily injury as the offender knows is likely to cause death.
Section 304 IPC covers cases where the intention or knowledge is not as strong as in murder or where there is an absence of premeditation, but the act still leads to death.
3. Key Distinctions Within Section 304 IPC
| Aspect | Section 304 Part I | Section 304 Part II |
|---|---|---|
| Intention | Intention to cause death or bodily injury likely to cause death | No intention to cause death, but knowledge that act likely to cause death |
| Knowledge | Not necessary if intention present | Knowledge of likelihood of death |
| Punishment | Up to 10 years imprisonment, or life imprisonment, or fine | Up to 10 years imprisonment, or fine, or both |
| Degree of Act | Higher degree of culpability | Lower degree of culpability |
4. Judicial Explanation and Subtle Distinctions by the Supreme Court
The Supreme Court of India has emphasized that the difference lies in the degree of the act and the intention or knowledge behind it, which differentiates culpable homicide from murder.
In Virsa Singh v. State of Punjab (1958 AIR 465): The Supreme Court laid down the principle that murder involves intention to cause death or knowledge that the act is so imminently dangerous that it must cause death. If this intention or knowledge is absent or less grave, the offence may be reduced to culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304.
In Raj Kishore v. State of Bihar (1963 AIR 1165): The Court held that the difference between murder and culpable homicide not amounting to murder lies in the intention and knowledge of the offender. The degree of knowledge required under Section 304 is less than that under Section 302.
In Gian Kaur v. State of Punjab (1996 AIR SC 946): The Court clarified that culpable homicide is not a term of strict legal significance but one of common usage; the distinction depends on the degree of intention and knowledge.
In State of Maharashtra v. Mayer Hans George (1965 AIR 722): The Court emphasized that the intention or knowledge to cause death or bodily injury differentiates culpable homicide from murder.
5. Summary of the Subtle Distinction
Culpable homicide under Section 304 IPC is about degree of culpability.
If a person intends to cause death or such bodily injury that is likely to cause death, but the act does not fulfill all conditions of murder (such as absence of premeditation or certain exceptions), it is Section 304 Part I.
If a person does an act with knowledge that it is likely to cause death but without intention, it is Section 304 Part II.
The Supreme Court clarifies that the distinction lies primarily in the mental state (mens rea) of the accused—intention vs. knowledge.
Punishment and gravity of offense correspond to this gradation in degree.
6. Important Case Laws Recap
| Case Name | Citation | Principle Established |
|---|---|---|
| Virsa Singh v. State of Punjab | AIR 1958 SC 465 | Difference between murder and culpable homicide depends on intention and knowledge. |
| Raj Kishore v. State of Bihar | AIR 1963 SC 1165 | The degree of knowledge in culpable homicide is less than murder. |
| Gian Kaur v. State of Punjab | AIR 1996 SC 946 | Explained the concept of culpable homicide and the gradation in intention/knowledge. |
| State of Maharashtra v. Mayer Hans George | AIR 1965 SC 722 | Clarified the role of intention and knowledge in distinguishing murder from culpable homicide. |
Conclusion
The Supreme Court of India clearly demarcates culpable homicide under Section 304 IPC from murder under Section 302 IPC by focusing on the degree of intention and knowledge. While murder requires a higher degree of intention or knowledge, culpable homicide recognizes a lesser degree of culpability, which reflects in the lesser punishment prescribed.
RELATED Blog
0 comments