Cyberbullying Legal Remedies
What is Cyberbullying?
Cyberbullying is the use of electronic communication to bully a person, typically by sending messages of an intimidating or threatening nature. It involves harassment, defamation, threats, or any form of harmful conduct carried out online or through digital platforms.
Legal Remedies Against Cyberbullying
Criminal Prosecution: Many jurisdictions treat cyberbullying as a criminal offense, punishable under laws relating to harassment, stalking, defamation, or threats.
Civil Lawsuits: Victims can file civil suits for damages for emotional distress, defamation, or invasion of privacy.
Restraining Orders: Courts can issue injunctions or protection orders to prevent further online harassment.
School Policies: Educational institutions may take disciplinary actions based on anti-bullying policies.
Internet Service Provider (ISP) Action: Victims can request the removal of harmful content or blocking of users.
Case Laws Illustrating Cyberbullying Remedies
1. Layshock v. Hermitage School District (2011) – United States
Facts: A high school student, Justin Layshock, created a parody profile of his principal on MySpace from his home computer.
Issue: The school suspended the student, claiming the profile disrupted school operations.
Court’s Decision: The Third Circuit Court ruled that the school violated the student's First Amendment rights by punishing him for off-campus speech that did not cause a substantial disruption in school.
Significance: This case protects students’ free speech rights, especially for online activities outside school, but cyberbullying causing disruption can still be regulated.
2. Doe v. Internet Brands, Inc. (2016) – United States
Facts: A woman was stalked and harassed by someone she met on a dating website operated by Internet Brands.
Issue: She sued Internet Brands for failing to warn users about the risk of sexual predators.
Court’s Decision: The Ninth Circuit allowed the lawsuit to proceed, holding that websites may have a duty to warn users of known dangers.
Significance: This case highlights the responsibility of online platforms in protecting users from cyber harassment.
3. State v. L.C. (2013) – New Jersey, United States
Facts: A student sent threatening text messages to another student.
Issue: Whether sending threats via text qualifies as criminal harassment.
Court’s Decision: The court upheld the conviction, stating electronic communications can be prosecuted under harassment laws.
Significance: Demonstrates that cyberbullying threats can be criminally punishable.
4. Sundaram v. State of Kerala (2018) – India
Facts: A woman was repeatedly harassed online by anonymous users posting defamatory content about her on social media.
Issue: The court had to decide whether the cyber harassment amounted to criminal defamation and harassment under Indian law.
Court’s Decision: The Kerala High Court held the accused liable and directed the police to investigate under the Information Technology Act and Indian Penal Code.
Significance: This case affirms legal protections against online defamation and harassment in India.
5. J.S. v. Blue Mountain School District (2011) – United States
Facts: A student was cyberbullied by classmates via online chat and MySpace.
Issue: Whether the school could be held liable for failing to protect the student.
Court’s Decision: The Third Circuit ruled the school was not liable because the bullying occurred off-campus and did not cause a substantial disruption in school.
Significance: Reiterates the limits of school authority over off-campus cyberbullying unless it materially affects school activities.
6. R v. Hayes (2015) – United Kingdom
Facts: A man repeatedly sent threatening and abusive messages online to a woman.
Issue: Prosecution for sending grossly offensive electronic communications.
Court’s Decision: The UK court convicted the defendant under the Communications Act 2003.
Significance: This case reinforces the criminal consequences of sending offensive or threatening messages online in the UK.
Summary of Legal Remedies
Criminal Law: Laws such as harassment, stalking, threats, and defamation apply to cyberbullying.
Civil Action: Victims can sue for damages caused by online bullying.
Restraining Orders: Courts can bar harassers from contacting victims.
School Discipline: Schools can discipline students for cyberbullying affecting the educational environment.
Platform Liability: Online service providers may have responsibilities to act on complaints of harassment.
RELATED Blog
0 comments