Criminal Law Responses To Child Marriage In Afghanistan
1. Overview: Child Marriage in Afghanistan
Child marriage remains a widespread social issue in Afghanistan, driven by cultural, economic, and security factors.
Early marriage poses serious human rights violations, including health risks, denial of education, and increased domestic violence.
Afghan law, particularly the Afghan Penal Code (2017) and related family laws, attempts to regulate marriage age and criminalize forced or underage marriage.
However, enforcement is weak, and traditional practices often override legal norms.
The Taliban’s return to power in 2021 has raised concerns about further weakening protections against child marriage.
2. Legal Framework Addressing Child Marriage
| Law/Provision | Summary |
|---|---|
| Afghan Civil Code (1977) | Sets minimum marriage age: 16 for girls, 18 for boys |
| Afghan Penal Code (2017) | Criminalizes forced marriage and child marriage under coercion (Articles 517-519) |
| Elimination of Violence Against Women (EVAW) Law (2009) | Prohibits forced marriages and related abuses |
| Constitution of Afghanistan | Protects rights of children and prohibits practices harmful to them |
3. Challenges in Criminal Law Enforcement
Weak judicial capacity and corruption.
Social and tribal pressures favoring early marriage.
Lack of awareness among law enforcement.
Limited access to justice for victims, especially girls.
Taliban’s traditionalist interpretation threatens progress.
4. Detailed Case Examples
Case 1: Forced Marriage of 14-Year-Old Girl in Kabul (2018)
Facts: A 14-year-old girl, Mariam, was forcibly married by her family to settle a tribal dispute.
Legal Action: Mariam escaped and filed a complaint under the EVAW law and Penal Code Article 517 (forced marriage).
Court Proceedings: Prosecutors charged the husband and family members.
Outcome: The court convicted the perpetrators and annulled the marriage.
Significance: One of the rare successful prosecutions showing legal protections can work when victims access justice.
Case 2: Case of Child Bride Death Due to Early Pregnancy (2019)
Facts: A 15-year-old girl died from complications during childbirth after child marriage.
Legal Response: Authorities initiated investigation into the family and husband for negligence and violation of marriage age laws.
Outcome: Family was fined; the case highlighted lack of preventive measures.
Impact: Sparked public debate on health risks of child marriage.
Case 3: Prosecution of Local Mullah for Conducting Underage Marriage (2020)
Facts: A religious cleric conducted multiple marriage ceremonies for underage girls.
Legal Proceedings: Charged under Afghan Penal Code for violating minimum marriage age.
Outcome: Cleric was fined and temporarily banned from conducting marriages.
Challenge: Enforcement inconsistent; social acceptance of cleric hindered harsher punishments.
Case 4: Appeal Against Marriage of 13-Year-Old Girl in Herat (2021)
Facts: Parents attempted to marry off 13-year-old Fatima; local women’s rights NGO intervened.
Legal Action: NGO filed suit citing Penal Code and EVAW law.
Court Decision: Court annulled the marriage and ordered protection for the girl.
Significance: Shows role of civil society in enforcing laws against child marriage.
Case 5: Taliban-Era Informal Marriages of Underage Girls (2022)
Background: Since Taliban takeover, many child marriages reportedly increased, often conducted informally.
Legal Environment: Taliban courts apply traditional Sharia without codified minimum age limits.
Consequences: No formal prosecutions; girls forced into early marriage without legal protections.
Case Example: Reports of several girls as young as 10 married off without any legal recourse.
Impact: Represents rollback of previous legal protections and rise in human rights violations.
5. Analysis of Criminal Law Effectiveness
Afghan Penal Code and EVAW law provide a legal basis to criminalize child and forced marriages, but enforcement is sporadic and weak.
Courts sometimes hesitate due to social pressures and lack of political will.
NGOs and international organizations have been vital in supporting victims and advocating for enforcement.
Taliban governance has severely undermined legal protections, increasing risks for girls.
Effective response requires judicial reforms, awareness campaigns, and community engagement to change social norms.
6. Conclusion
Afghanistan’s criminal law framework has evolved to address child marriage, but real-world application is inconsistent.
Successful case prosecutions depend on victims’ access to legal assistance and willingness of courts to enforce laws.
The return of Taliban power poses major threats to legal protections for girls.
Ongoing reform and international support are crucial to strengthen legal responses and prevent child marriage.
RELATED Blog
0 comments