Law of Evidence at Lebanon
The Law of Evidence in Lebanon is primarily governed by the Lebanese Code of Civil Procedure (Code de Procédure Civile) and the Lebanese Penal Code, with significant influences from French civil law, Islamic law, and the Madhhab (Jurisprudence) system followed by different religious communities in Lebanon. Lebanon is a pluralistic society with various religious groups, each having its own legal system or "personal status laws," especially in matters related to family law. However, the laws surrounding evidence in civil and criminal cases are more unified.
Key Aspects of Evidence Law in Lebanon:
🔹 1. Types of Evidence in Lebanon
In Criminal Law:
Testimony (Shahada) of Witnesses:
Witness testimony is a critical form of evidence in Lebanon, as in many legal systems. Witnesses are typically required to testify under oath, and their testimony can be challenged or supported by other evidence. The credibility and reliability of a witness are assessed by the judge.
Confessions (Iqrār):
A confession by the defendant is considered significant evidence in criminal cases. However, confessions must be voluntary, and any confession obtained under duress, torture, or coercion is inadmissible. The defendant has the right to retract their confession, and the court will examine the circumstances under which it was made.
Documents (Wathiqa):
Written documents are highly valued in Lebanon’s legal system. These could be anything from contracts to official records and other forms of written evidence. Documents must be proven to be authentic for them to be admitted in court.
Physical Evidence (Adillah Madiyyah):
Physical evidence, such as weapons, clothing, DNA samples, or any material that can be linked to the crime, is also accepted. Forensic analysis (e.g., DNA, fingerprints) can be crucial in many criminal cases, especially in modern investigations.
Expert Testimony (Shahadat al-Khabar):
Expert testimony is crucial, particularly in cases involving technical or scientific matters, such as forensics or medical issues. Experts in various fields can testify to help the court understand complex evidence.
Circumstantial Evidence (Qayisat):
Indirect evidence or circumstantial evidence can be used to infer facts and establish connections between events. While it does not directly prove the facts, it can still be influential, especially in the absence of direct evidence.
In Civil Law:
Witness Testimony (Shahada):
Just as in criminal cases, witness testimony is an essential form of evidence in civil disputes, whether it’s for contractual matters, property disputes, or family law matters.
Documents (Wathiqa):
In civil law, documents are paramount, particularly when proving obligations, contracts, or transactions. Signed contracts, bank statements, and other records are considered highly persuasive.
Presumptions (Ijtihad):
Presumptions are used in civil cases when direct evidence is lacking. This could be in the form of generalizations that help fill in gaps, based on logic or prior experience. For example, if someone is seen entering a house, it can be presumed they are a tenant, unless proven otherwise.
🔹 2. Burden of Proof
In Criminal Cases: The burden of proof in criminal cases is on the prosecution (state), and the accused is presumed innocent until proven guilty. The standard of proof required is usually beyond a reasonable doubt. This means that the evidence must be sufficient and strong enough to leave no reasonable doubt about the defendant’s guilt.
In Civil Cases: The burden of proof in civil cases lies with the party making the claim (usually the plaintiff), who must prove their case by a preponderance of the evidence. This is a lower standard than in criminal cases, meaning that the party must simply prove that their claim is more likely true than not.
🔹 3. Evaluation and Admissibility of Evidence
The evaluation of evidence in Lebanon is typically at the discretion of the judge. However, there are general principles that govern how evidence is treated:
Admissibility of Evidence:
Evidence is considered admissible if it is relevant, material, and not obtained unlawfully. The judge will assess whether the evidence helps prove or disprove key points in the case.
In criminal cases, the voluntariness of confessions and the authenticity of documents are crucial to their admissibility.
Role of the Judge:
Judges in Lebanon have a significant role in evaluating the evidence. They are not bound by rigid rules of evidence but must ensure that they are fair and just in their consideration of all evidence presented.
Reliability and Corroboration:
In both criminal and civil cases, evidence must be reliable. The judge may require corroboration of witness testimony with other forms of evidence, especially in serious cases like murder or fraud.
🔹 4. Special Considerations
Confessions and the Death Penalty:
In cases involving serious charges, such as murder, confessions can be pivotal, but Lebanese law protects the rights of individuals under investigation. The use of confessions extracted under torture or force is prohibited, and these confessions will not be considered valid.
Religious Courts:
Religious courts have jurisdiction over personal status laws in Lebanon (marriage, divorce, inheritance, etc.) for individuals belonging to different religious sects. These courts may rely on religious texts and interpretations, which can affect how evidence is treated in personal status cases.
Digital Evidence:
The use of digital evidence, such as emails, phone records, social media posts, and digital contracts, is becoming increasingly important, especially in cases involving cybercrimes, fraud, or defamation. Lebanon has introduced some laws to regulate digital transactions and electronic evidence.
🔹 5. Modern Trends and Legal Reforms
Digital and Electronic Evidence: Lebanon has started to recognize the importance of digital evidence, especially in the context of cybercrime laws. There has been progress in creating frameworks for electronic contracts, digital signatures, and e-evidence.
Strengthening Legal Protections: There is a growing interest in witness protection and the improvement of laws that protect whistleblowers. This is particularly relevant in cases involving corruption or organized crime.
Conclusion
The Law of Evidence in Lebanon is a blend of civil law traditions, Islamic law, and French influence. The Lebanese legal system gives substantial weight to witness testimony, confessions, and written documents. In both criminal and civil cases, evidence is evaluated by the judge, who has considerable discretion to determine its relevance and weight. Recent trends indicate growing attention to digital evidence and the protection of witnesses and victims in high-stakes cases.
RELATED Blog
0 comments