Arbitration Law in Russia
Arbitration law in Russia is governed by a combination of federal laws, international treaties, and judicial practice. The primary legislation on arbitration in Russia is the Arbitration Procedure Code of the Russian Federation (APC) and the Federal Law on International Commercial Arbitration (Law No. 5338-1). Below is a detailed overview of the arbitration framework in Russia:
1. Legal Framework
- Arbitration Procedure Code (APC): This is the main body of law that governs both domestic and international arbitration in Russia. It covers various aspects of arbitration, including the appointment of arbitrators, procedural rules, and the enforcement of awards.
- Federal Law on International Commercial Arbitration (No. 5338-1, 1993): This law governs international arbitration and is based on the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration. It provides the legal framework for international arbitration in Russia.
- Constitution of the Russian Federation: The Constitution guarantees the right to arbitration and upholds the principle of arbitration as a viable method for dispute resolution.
- New York Convention (1958): Russia is a signatory to the New York Convention, which allows for the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards.
2. Arbitration Agreement
- In Russia, arbitration can only take place if the parties have a valid arbitration agreement, which can either be an arbitration clause in a contract or a separate arbitration agreement that specifically refers to resolving a dispute through arbitration.
- The agreement must be in writing. It can be in any form, including in electronic or digital form, provided there is an acknowledgment of consent to arbitration.
- The arbitration agreement must explicitly refer to arbitration and cannot be unilateral or conditional in nature.
3. Arbitral Tribunal
- The arbitral tribunal in Russia can consist of one or more arbitrators, depending on the agreement between the parties.
- The parties have the autonomy to select arbitrators. In the case of disputes over the selection of arbitrators, a court may intervene to appoint them.
- Arbitrators must be independent and impartial. There are no specific qualifications required by law, but the parties can agree on the qualifications of the arbitrators in their arbitration agreement.
- If there is a failure to agree on the number or appointment of arbitrators, the Russian courts may intervene to appoint them.
4. Arbitration Procedure
- The arbitration procedure is flexible and can be tailored to the parties’ preferences. If the parties have not agreed on a procedure, the arbitrators have the authority to determine the rules and procedures, but they must ensure fairness, due process, and the right to be heard.
- Russian domestic arbitration is primarily governed by the Arbitration Procedure Code, which outlines procedures for commencing arbitration, hearings, evidence presentation, and the issuance of awards.
- International arbitration can follow different procedural rules, depending on the arbitration agreement, but Russian courts generally recognize the principle of party autonomy in determining the rules to be applied.
- A party seeking arbitration must file a statement of claim with the arbitral tribunal, which then decides on the venue, schedule, and other procedural aspects.
5. Arbitral Awards
- After conducting the proceedings, the arbitral tribunal issues an award, which is binding on the parties. The award must be in writing, and it must include the reasoning behind the decision.
- Arbitral awards in Russia are enforceable, but they can be challenged on limited grounds such as:
- Violation of Russian public policy.
- Lack of jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal.
- Procedural violations during the arbitration process.
- Failure to properly notify a party of the proceedings.
- The Russian court system allows for a judicial review of arbitral awards, but it is generally limited and only on the above grounds.
6. Recognition and Enforcement of Arbitral Awards
- Russia is a party to the New York Convention, which facilitates the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards in Russia and vice versa.
- A foreign arbitral award must be recognized and enforced by a Russian court, which will examine whether the award complies with Russian public policy and the requirements of the New York Convention.
- Domestic arbitral awards are generally easier to enforce within Russia, and enforcement actions can be initiated in Russian courts.
7. Judicial Review and Setting Aside of Awards
- The Russian courts have the authority to set aside or refuse to enforce an arbitral award. The grounds for setting aside an award are limited, and courts typically do not review the merits of the case or the arbitrators' findings.
- Grounds for setting aside an award include:
- The arbitration agreement was invalid or unenforceable.
- The arbitrators did not have jurisdiction to hear the dispute.
- There was a serious violation of due process.
- The award is contrary to Russian public policy.
- A party seeking to set aside an arbitral award must file a request with a Russian court. The court has the discretion to annul the award based on these grounds.
8. Institutional vs. Ad Hoc Arbitration
- Institutional Arbitration: Russia has several prominent arbitral institutions, such as:
- The Russian Arbitration Association (RAA).
- The Moscow Court of International Commercial Arbitration (ICAC), which is one of the most well-known institutions for resolving disputes involving international commercial arbitration.
- Other international institutions, such as the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) or London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA), are also recognized in Russia for arbitration.
- Ad Hoc Arbitration: Parties may also opt for ad hoc arbitration, where they appoint their own arbitrators and agree on the arbitration procedure. Ad hoc arbitration in Russia is often used in international disputes and is governed by the Federal Law on International Commercial Arbitration.
9. International Arbitration
- Russia supports international arbitration and is a member of several key international arbitration treaties, including the New York Convention and the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements.
- Arbitration institutions such as the ICC, LCIA, and SCC (Stockholm Chamber of Commerce) have arbitration centers in Russia. Foreign arbitrators are often selected for disputes involving parties from multiple jurisdictions.
10. Recent Developments
- Russia has been making efforts to improve its arbitration framework to make it more attractive for international commercial disputes. The Russian Federation’s Arbitration Law is continuously evolving to align with international arbitration standards.
- The Russian Supreme Court has also worked to clarify the application of the law in arbitration matters, providing more predictability and consistency in judicial reviews.
Conclusion:
Arbitration in Russia is governed by a robust legal framework, including both domestic and international arbitration laws. It offers an efficient alternative to litigation, with a strong emphasis on party autonomy. While the legal system provides for a limited scope of judicial review, the recognition and enforcement of arbitration awards are generally favorable, especially in accordance with international treaties like the New York Convention.
RELATED Blog
0 comments