Media laws at Israel
Media Laws in Israel
Israel has a dynamic media landscape characterized by a high degree of press freedom, as well as regulations that balance freedom of expression with concerns such as national security, public order, and defamation. The country’s media laws are influenced by democratic principles and international human rights standards, but also by the complex security situation in the region.
Here is an overview of media laws in Israel:
1. Constitutional and Legal Framework
Freedom of Expression: Israel’s Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty (1992) guarantees freedom of expression, which is a cornerstone of the country's democracy. Although Israel does not have a single, written constitution, its Basic Laws function as constitutional principles, providing the foundation for legal protections, including for the media.
Article 7 of this law asserts that every person has the right to express their opinions, including in the media, unless limited by a law that serves a worthy public purpose.
2. Key Media Laws and Regulations
A. The Press Ordinance (1933)
The Press Ordinance is a legacy law dating back to the British Mandate period, which remains part of the legal framework in Israel. The ordinance establishes the principles for the registration of newspapers and press permits.
It gives the Israeli authorities the power to ban publications that are deemed harmful to national security or public order. This law also mandates that press outlets must be registered, and it imposes criminal penalties for spreading false or harmful information that could damage public order.
B. The Broadcasting Law (1965)
The Broadcasting Law (1965) established the framework for regulating broadcast media in Israel. The law created Israel Broadcasting Authority (IBA), which was responsible for public television and radio broadcasting.
In 2017, the Israel Broadcasting Authority (IBA) was replaced by the Kan Broadcasting Corporation (KAN), which is responsible for the public broadcasting sector in Israel.
The law also provides for licensing of private broadcasters and places requirements on broadcasting content, including the need to represent a diverse range of views and comply with public interest standards.
C. The Law of Defamation (1965)
The Defamation Law (1965) governs defamation cases in Israel and provides individuals the right to seek legal recourse if they feel that their reputation has been harmed by false statements made in the media.
The law includes provisions for both libel (written defamation) and slander (spoken defamation). The law specifies remedies such as damages and allows defendants to use a variety of defenses, including truth, fair comment, and public interest.
Media outlets are particularly subject to scrutiny under defamation laws, especially regarding public figures, who are subject to heightened standards for defamation claims.
D. The Anti-Terrorism Law (2016)
The Anti-Terrorism Law (2016) introduces restrictions on media reporting in the context of national security. The law grants the Israeli military censor the authority to block or restrict publication of certain information if it is deemed to compromise national security, including information related to military operations, intelligence, and counterterrorism efforts.
Censorship is applied to military matters, and journalists can be legally required to submit reports to the military censor before publication if they deal with sensitive security issues.
3. Regulatory Bodies
A. Israeli Broadcasting Authority (IBA) / Kan Broadcasting Corporation (KAN)
The Israeli Broadcasting Authority (IBA) was responsible for public radio and television broadcasting in Israel until its replacement by KAN in 2017.
KAN oversees public television, radio, and digital platforms in Israel and operates under the supervision of the Israel Public Broadcasting Corporation.
It is tasked with providing public interest programming and ensuring content diversity, as well as adhering to ethical standards.
B. The Second Authority for Television and Radio
The Second Authority for Television and Radio is responsible for regulating commercial television and radio channels in Israel. It oversees the licensing process and ensures that private broadcasters adhere to national standards, including content diversity, news balance, and fairness.
This authority also handles the allocation of frequencies for private broadcasters.
C. The Government Press Office (GPO)
The Government Press Office (GPO) is responsible for the relationship between the government and the media. The GPO provides journalists with access to government information and press releases and can facilitate access to high-level government officials.
The GPO also issues press cards to accredited journalists.
4. Press Freedom and Media Environment
Press Freedom: Israel enjoys a high level of press freedom, with a diverse media landscape that includes both private and public outlets. Israel's media is free to report on a wide range of issues, including government policies, social issues, and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Freedom of the Press vs. National Security: While press freedom is a cornerstone of Israeli democracy, national security concerns often lead to restrictions on the media, particularly in relation to coverage of military operations and intelligence matters. The military censor can place gag orders on certain stories that might pose a threat to national security.
Self-Regulation and Ethical Standards: The Israeli media is largely self-regulated through various professional organizations, such as the Israeli Journalists Association. These organizations establish ethical codes for reporting and ensure that journalists adhere to professional standards.
5. Defamation and Libel
Israel has comprehensive defamation laws that allow both individuals and public figures to sue for damages if they believe their reputation has been harmed by media reporting.
The Defamation Law (1965) gives legal recourse to those harmed by false statements, with the option of seeking remedies in court.
However, Israel also allows a defense of truth in defamation cases, meaning that if the published information is proven to be true, the defendant can avoid liability.
The law is particularly relevant when it comes to public figures, as it places a higher burden on them to prove harm.
6. Broadcasting and Media Ownership
Ownership of Broadcast Media: In Israel, the ownership of television and radio channels is regulated to ensure media diversity and prevent monopolistic control over public discourse. Both public and private media are subject to regulatory oversight by bodies such as the Second Authority for Television and Radio.
Public broadcasters, such as KAN, are funded by the government but are expected to provide impartial and diverse programming.
Private broadcasters must adhere to licensing conditions and regulations that aim to promote diverse viewpoints and balance in news coverage.
Press Ownership: Israel has a relatively concentrated media market, with a few major media conglomerates controlling a significant portion of the media. This has raised concerns about the level of media pluralism and the influence of media owners on editorial content.
7. Social Media and Online Content
Social Media Regulation: Social media platforms in Israel are generally subject to the same laws as traditional media, particularly when it comes to defamation and incitement to violence. Israel has strict laws regarding hate speech and incitement, which also apply to content shared on platforms like Facebook and Twitter.
In 2017, the Israeli government passed a law requiring social media companies to remove content deemed incitement to violence, terrorism, or racism within 48 hours of receiving a court order. Failure to comply can result in fines.
Online Censorship: The government can request that social media companies remove content that might threaten national security or public order. However, the issue of censorship is controversial, as it often raises concerns about free speech and government overreach in online platforms.
8. Hate Speech and Content Regulation
Hate Speech: Israeli law prohibits the publication of content that incites hatred, violence, or discrimination against individuals or groups based on their ethnicity, religion, or other protected characteristics. Hate speech laws are intended to prevent the spread of extremist views and the incitement of violence.
The Prevention of Terrorism Act (2016) criminalizes the promotion of terrorist acts and includes provisions for prosecuting media outlets that encourage violence or terror.
Censorship and National Security: Media coverage of military and security-related matters is often subject to censorship. The military censor has the authority to prevent the publication of information that might harm national security, and journalists must comply with these restrictions if their stories touch on sensitive security issues.
9. International Considerations and Challenges
Israel is subject to international law, including United Nations resolutions and European Union standards (in cases of cooperation or trade). However, its legal framework is primarily shaped by domestic law rather than international norms.
Media freedoms in Israel are sometimes impacted by the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, with journalists facing unique challenges, including censorship, violent threats, and restrictions on movement in conflict zones. This can lead to tensions between press freedom and security concerns.
Summary Table: Media Laws in Israel
| Aspect | Status |
|---|---|
| Freedom of Press | Protected by Basic Law, but subject to limitations regarding national security and defamation |
| Defamation | Governed by Defamation Law (1965); public figures have fewer protections, but truth is a defense |
| Broadcasting | Regulated by Broadcasting Law (1965) and Kan Broadcasting Corporation; public and private broadcasters subject to content standards |
| Social Media Regulation | Social media platforms must comply with hate speech and incitement laws, and remove harmful content within 48 hours |
| Press Complaints | Complaints can be made under defamation law; self-regulation by journalists' associations |
| Public Media | Kan Broadcasting Corporation provides public service programming; funded by government but independent in content |
| Media Ownership | Concentrated ownership, but laws in place to regulate monopolies and promote diversity in broadcasting |
| Hate Speech | Prohibited, with strict regulations against incitement to violence, terrorism, or racism |
| Censorship | National security concerns lead to censorship of military and intelligence-related content |
Conclusion:
Israel has a strong tradition of press freedom, but this is balanced by concerns over national security and defamation laws. The media is largely self-regulated, and broadcasters must adhere to legal standards that promote diversity and public interest. Social media is subject to censorship and regulations, particularly around hate speech and incitement. While the media plays a crucial role in Israel’s democracy, it faces challenges related to security concerns and ownership concentration.
RELATED Blog
0 comments