Military Law at Palestine
Military law in Palestine is shaped by the unique and complex political situation in the region, including the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the lack of full sovereignty, and the division between the Palestinian Authority (PA) and Hamas in the Gaza Strip. The legal framework for military law in Palestine is affected by both domestic laws and the broader international context.
Here’s an overview of military law in Palestine, including key institutions, legal frameworks, and challenges:
1. Political and Legal Context
Palestine is recognized by many countries and international organizations as a state, although it does not have full control over its territory. The State of Palestine is recognized by over 130 countries and has been a non-member observer state in the United Nations since 2012. However, its territories—the West Bank, Gaza Strip, and East Jerusalem—are under Israeli occupation or control, and the region remains politically divided between the Palestinian Authority (PA) and Hamas.
Palestinian Authority (PA): The PA is the semi-governmental body controlling parts of the West Bank and is recognized by much of the international community as the representative of the Palestinian people. The PA operates under the framework of the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO).
Hamas: Hamas, an Islamist militant group, controls the Gaza Strip. Hamas and the PA have been in conflict since 2007, resulting in the political division between the West Bank and Gaza.
Israeli Occupation: Israel continues to control large parts of the West Bank and all of East Jerusalem, while the Gaza Strip is under blockade by Israel and Egypt, despite Hamas' control. The Israeli military’s presence in the region heavily influences the security environment and the enforcement of military law.
2. Military Forces and Security Institutions in Palestine
There are two main Palestinian security organizations responsible for military and security functions:
Palestinian Authority Security Forces: Under the PA, the security forces are responsible for maintaining law and order in the areas under PA control in the West Bank. These forces include:
Palestinian National Security Forces: This includes infantry, special units, and police forces responsible for internal security, border control (in areas under PA authority), and law enforcement.
Palestinian Civil Police: The civil police handle non-military law enforcement duties, including investigations and civil matters.
Intelligence Services: The PA has intelligence agencies to manage national security and counter-terrorism efforts.
Hamas Military Wing (Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades): Hamas operates its own military wing, which is heavily involved in defense and security within the Gaza Strip. The Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades are responsible for armed resistance against Israel and internal enforcement of Hamas’s policies in Gaza. They maintain their own military laws and codes of conduct, independent of the PA's military framework.
3. Military Law in the Palestinian Authority (PA) Areas
The PA applies military law to its security forces, which is based on a mixture of Jordanian laws (from the period when the West Bank was under Jordanian rule), Egyptian laws (from the period when Gaza was under Egyptian administration), and laws passed by the Palestinian Legislative Council.
Palestinian Military Law: The legal framework for military law in the West Bank is derived from the Palestinian Military Justice Law (No. 1 of 2007), which was enacted by the Palestinian Legislative Council (PLC). This law regulates the functions of the Palestinian military courts and the legal status of military personnel under the PA.
Military Justice System: The military justice system under the PA includes military courts, which deal with offenses committed by military personnel or individuals related to national security. The military courts are distinct from the civilian judicial system, though they operate under the oversight of the Palestinian Minister of Justice.
Crimes Under Military Law: Military law in the PA areas deals with a range of offenses, including insubordination, desertion, collaboration with Israel, and other national security-related offenses. Military personnel who violate these laws face court-martials or other forms of military justice, including imprisonment.
Role of Civilian Courts: The civilian legal system is also involved in cases where the violation impacts civilian life, particularly when military actions by PA security forces affect Palestinian civilians.
4. Military Law in Gaza under Hamas
In the Gaza Strip, Hamas applies its own version of military law, which is distinct from that in the West Bank. As the de facto authority in Gaza, Hamas has its own military structures and legal system, including its military justice system.
Hamas Military Law: Hamas operates under a combination of Islamic law (Sharia) and military law derived from their resistance-based ideology. The Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades are responsible for both military defense against Israel and internal policing in Gaza.
Sharia Law: Hamas integrates Sharia law principles in its legal framework, including punishment for crimes such as theft, apostasy, and insurrection. These principles are applied in the military context to enforce discipline among Hamas military personnel.
Military Courts: In Gaza, military personnel are tried in military courts overseen by Hamas. These courts handle violations such as desertion, insubordination, and collaboration with Israel. For offenses perceived as undermining the state or Hamas's rule, severe punishments can be imposed, including execution.
5. Israeli Military Law and Impact on Palestine
The Israeli military plays a central role in the everyday life of Palestinians, especially in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. The Israeli military enforces its own set of military laws and regulations in the occupied territories, impacting Palestinians in various ways.
Israeli Military Courts in the West Bank: Under Israeli military law, Palestinians in the West Bank are subject to Israeli military courts, even for civilian offenses. Palestinians accused of offenses such as stone-throwing, organizing protests, or participating in armed resistance may be tried in these military courts.
Detention Without Trial: Israel has a practice of administrative detention, where individuals can be detained for extended periods without trial, based on security concerns.
Military Laws and Punishments: Israeli military law includes a broad range of offenses, and penalties can include imprisonment, fines, or expulsion from areas like Jerusalem or the West Bank.
6. International Law and Human Rights Concerns
Palestine, particularly in the West Bank and Gaza, is subject to a variety of international legal standards that apply to military operations and human rights. These include:
Geneva Conventions: Both Israel and Palestinian authorities are bound by international humanitarian law, including the Geneva Conventions, which govern the conduct of armed forces and the protection of civilians during armed conflict.
Occupying Power: As an occupying power in the West Bank and East Jerusalem, Israel has a responsibility to ensure the well-being of Palestinian civilians and is bound by international law regarding the treatment of civilians under occupation.
Human Rights Violations: Both Israel and Palestinian groups have been accused of human rights violations. For example, Palestinian groups like Hamas have faced criticism for their use of militant tactics and attacks on civilians. Likewise, Israel has been criticized for its use of disproportionate force and treatment of Palestinian prisoners in military courts.
7. Challenges and Considerations
Internal Divisions: The division between the PA and Hamas presents challenges for the coherence of military law in Palestine. Each faction has its own military justice system and practices, leading to inconsistent enforcement of laws across the Palestinian territories.
Occupation and Autonomy: The ongoing Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza’s blockade by Israel create an environment where both Palestinian groups must navigate military laws imposed by an external power (Israel) while also enforcing their own military laws.
Human Rights: There are ongoing concerns about the treatment of prisoners, including allegations of torture and unfair trials, particularly in Israeli military courts and in the territories under Palestinian control. The rights of civilians, especially in areas of active conflict, are a major concern under both Palestinian and Israeli military law.
Conclusion
Military law in Palestine is shaped by the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the split between Hamas and the Palestinian Authority, and the complex political environment. The Palestinian Authority and Hamas each have their own military justice systems, but both operate under significant constraints due to the ongoing occupation by Israel and international pressure. The situation remains fluid and deeply affected by the wider geopolitical and humanitarian context, with human rights and international law playing an important role in the discourse surrounding military law and military activities in the region.
RELATED Blog
0 comments