Military Law at Eritrea
Military Law in Eritrea
Eritrea, located in the Horn of Africa, has a military system that is deeply influenced by its history of armed struggle for independence and its current security challenges. Military law in Eritrea governs the conduct, duties, and discipline of the Eritrean Defense Forces (EDF), which is the country's primary military body. The legal framework for military operations in Eritrea is shaped by national laws, the Constitution of Eritrea, and international treaties, though the country’s political system has influenced the practical application of military law.
1. The Eritrean Defense Forces (EDF)
The Eritrean Defense Forces (EDF) is the national military force of Eritrea, and it includes several branches:
Army: The largest and most significant branch, responsible for land-based operations and the defense of the country's borders.
Navy: The naval forces, which operate in Eritrea's Red Sea coastal areas, are relatively small but play a strategic role in the defense of the country's maritime interests.
Air Force: Eritrea's air force is focused on defending the country's airspace and supporting ground operations.
Military service is compulsory for all Eritrean citizens, which is a hallmark of the country's defense policy.
2. Legal Framework Governing Military Law
The legal framework governing military law in Eritrea is primarily shaped by national legislation, including the Constitution, military codes, and regulations. However, the implementation of these laws is often influenced by the central government, which maintains strict control over both the military and civilian institutions.
a. The Constitution of Eritrea (1997)
The Constitution of Eritrea (ratified in 1997 but not formally implemented) establishes the foundation for Eritrean governance, including military matters. Some of the key provisions include:
National Defense: The Constitution mandates that the defense of the country is a responsibility of all citizens, and the military is tasked with defending Eritrea’s sovereignty and territorial integrity.
Civilian Oversight: While the President holds significant control over the armed forces (as the Commander-in-Chief), the Constitution envisions a role for civilian oversight. However, the practical application of this principle has been limited due to the country’s authoritarian political structure.
Military Service: The Constitution affirms the obligation of all citizens, especially men, to engage in national service, which includes military service.
b. National Service Law (1995)
One of the most significant aspects of Eritrean military law is the National Service Law (1995), which mandates compulsory military service for all male citizens aged 18 and above. Key aspects of this law include:
Universal Conscription: All Eritrean citizens are required to serve in the military, typically for a period of 18 months, after which they are placed in the reserve forces.
Service Requirements: National service includes both military training and civil service, but the military component is the primary focus, with conscripts undergoing extensive training and being placed in various military units.
Extensions and Forced Conscription: The law allows the government to extend the length of service beyond the initial period, sometimes indefinitely, and conscripts are often called upon to serve for much longer durations.
c. The Military Penal Code
Eritrea’s Military Penal Code regulates the legal framework for the conduct of military personnel, defining military offenses and the corresponding punishments. The code aims to maintain discipline within the armed forces and ensure that soldiers adhere to the rules of engagement and other military regulations. Some key elements of the Military Penal Code include:
Desertion and Absence: Desertion or unauthorized absence from military duty is treated as a serious offense, with harsh penalties, including imprisonment.
Insubordination: Military personnel who refuse to obey lawful orders or engage in acts of insubordination can face penalties ranging from reprimands to dismissal or imprisonment.
Mutiny: Any form of collective insubordination or rebellion against superiors is considered a serious offense and may result in severe legal consequences.
Misuse of Military Resources: The unauthorized use or theft of military equipment or resources is prohibited and may lead to significant disciplinary actions.
War Crimes: Eritrea, like many countries, is bound by international humanitarian law, including the Geneva Conventions, which prohibit the mistreatment of prisoners of war and civilians during armed conflict. Military personnel found guilty of violating these laws can face prosecution under the military justice system.
3. Military Courts and Military Justice System
Eritrea has a system of military courts that deal with offenses committed by members of the armed forces. The military justice system is distinct from civilian courts and is focused on maintaining discipline and order within the military.
a. Structure of Military Courts
Military Tribunals: The lowest-level military courts that handle less severe offenses. These tribunals typically handle cases of minor violations of military regulations, such as absence without leave (AWOL) or small infractions.
Military Court of First Instance: For more serious offenses, a higher military court is responsible for trying cases, including those involving desertion, insubordination, and breaches of military discipline.
Appeals Court: Military personnel found guilty in lower courts can appeal their cases to the military appeals court. However, the appeal process is often limited, and the chances for a fair trial are debated.
Special Courts: In cases of wartime conduct or severe offenses like mutiny or treason, the government may establish special military tribunals to handle such cases quickly and decisively.
b. Jurisdiction of Military Courts
Military courts in Eritrea have exclusive jurisdiction over offenses committed by military personnel during their service. Civilian courts do not generally handle military crimes, and the military justice system operates independently of civilian courts. This means that soldiers, regardless of the crime, will be tried under military law rather than civilian law.
c. Military Offenses and Punishments
The Military Penal Code outlines a wide range of military offenses and corresponding punishments. These offenses typically include:
Desertion: Leaving military duty without permission, a crime that is punished harshly, often with imprisonment.
Mutiny: Any form of collective insubordination or disobedience against the government or military leadership.
Insubordination: Refusing to obey orders from superiors.
Theft or Misuse of Military Property: Stealing or misusing military equipment or supplies is considered a serious crime.
War Crimes and Atrocities: Violations of international humanitarian law, including mistreatment of prisoners or civilians, are considered grave offenses.
Punishments under military law in Eritrea can range from:
Reprimands or Warnings: For minor offenses.
Imprisonment: For offenses like desertion, insubordination, or theft.
Dishonorable Discharge: Soldiers convicted of serious crimes may be discharged dishonorably, losing any benefits or pensions.
Death Penalty: In the case of extreme offenses, such as mutiny or treason, the death penalty may be applied, although its use is rare.
4. Military Service and Conscription
In Eritrea, compulsory military service is one of the cornerstones of national defense. Both men and women are required to serve in the military, but the law primarily targets men aged 18 and above.
a. National Service Law (1995)
As previously mentioned, the National Service Law enforces conscription for all citizens. Key aspects of this law include:
Mandatory Service: All male citizens are required to serve in the military for a period of 18 months. Women can voluntarily join the military, though they also participate in national service, which often includes both civil and military roles.
Indefinite Service: The Eritrean government has used national service as a means of maintaining a large, ready military force. It is not uncommon for conscripts to remain in the military or national service for many years after completing their initial period of duty.
Training and Deployment: National service recruits undergo rigorous military training and may be deployed to various parts of the country, often in high-risk regions.
b. Child Soldiers
There have been concerns and reports about the use of child soldiers in Eritrea, although the government officially denies this. Despite these reports, Eritrea has made efforts to comply with international conventions prohibiting the recruitment of minors into the military.
5. Civilian Control and Oversight
Eritrea’s civilian control over the military is nominal, as the country is a one-party state with significant centralized power under the ruling regime. The President of Eritrea, currently Isaias Afwerki, holds immense control over both the military and the civilian government. The Ministry of Defense, under presidential control, oversees military operations, policy, and national service.
While the Constitution outlines some form of civilian oversight, the authoritarian nature of the regime has limited the practical application of these principles. The Eritrean People's Liberation Front (EPLF), the ruling party, has close ties to the military, making civilian oversight more difficult in practice.
6. International and Regional Role
Eritrea’s military plays a significant role in regional security. The country has a history of involvement in conflicts with neighboring states, including Ethiopia during the Eritrean-Ethiopian War (1998-2000) and ongoing tensions with Djibouti and Somalia. Eritrean forces have also been involved in peacekeeping and intervention missions across the Horn of Africa.
Eritrea is a member of the African Union and is bound by international conventions, including the Geneva Conventions, which govern the conduct of military personnel in armed conflicts. The country, however, has faced criticism for its human rights record and its treatment of prisoners of war and civilians during past conflicts.
Conclusion
Military law in Eritrea is characterized by compulsory military service, strict military discipline, and a centralized system of command under the control of the President. The Eritrean Defense Forces (EDF) are governed by national legislation, including the National Service Law and the Military Penal Code, which outline military offenses and corresponding punishments. The military justice system is independent of civilian courts and deals exclusively with offenses committed by military personnel.
Eritrea's military plays a critical role in the country’s defense policy, but its practices, including the use of extended conscription and allegations of human rights violations, have drawn international criticism. Despite the legal frameworks in place, the country’s political system has resulted in limited civilian oversight, and the military remains under tight government control.
RELATED Blog
0 comments