Civil Laws at Hong Kong
Hong Kong operates a common law legal system, distinct from mainland China's civil law system, under the principle of "One Country, Two Systems." This unique arrangement is enshrined in the Basic Law, Hong Kong's mini-constitution, which guarantees the continuation of its capitalist system and way of life, including its common law traditions, for 50 years after the 1997 handover.
1. Sources of Civil Law in Hong Kong:
The civil law in Hong Kong is derived from several primary sources, in hierarchical order:
The Basic Law: This is the constitutional document of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (HKSAR). It sets out the fundamental policies of the PRC regarding Hong Kong, guarantees the continuation of the common law system (Article 8), and protects fundamental rights and freedoms, including civil rights. Any law that contravenes the Basic Law is unconstitutional and invalid.
Common Law and Rules of Equity: These are judge-made laws that originated in England and have been developed over centuries through judicial precedents.
Common Law: Decisions of higher courts are binding on lower courts (the doctrine of stare decisis). This ensures consistency and predictability in legal outcomes. Hong Kong courts can also refer to precedents from other common law jurisdictions.
Rules of Equity: These are principles developed to supplement the strictness of common law, providing fairness and discretion to judges. Equitable remedies include injunctions (court orders to stop an action) and specific performance (court orders to fulfill a contract).
Ordinances (Statute Law): Laws enacted by the Legislative Council of Hong Kong. These are written laws that can codify, modify, or introduce new legal principles. A significant portion of Hong Kong's civil law is now codified in various ordinances.
Subordinate Legislation: Laws made under the authority of an Ordinance, such as regulations, rules, and by-laws.
Certain National Laws: While generally, national laws of the People's Republic of China do not apply in Hong Kong, a specific and limited list of national laws (primarily concerning defense and foreign affairs, or other matters outside Hong Kong's autonomy) are applied by being listed in Annex III of the Basic Law. For example, the National Security Law, enacted in 2020 by the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, is a national law that applies directly in Hong Kong.
2. Key Areas of Civil Law in Hong Kong:
Civil law in Hong Kong covers a vast array of legal relationships and disputes between private parties (individuals, companies, organizations) and sometimes against the government. Key areas include:
Contract Law: Governs the formation, validity, performance, and breach of contracts, as well as remedies for breach. Hong Kong's contract law largely mirrors English common law principles, emphasizing freedom of contract.
Tort Law: Deals with civil wrongs that cause harm to another, leading to civil liability. Common torts include:
Negligence: Causing harm due to carelessness.
Defamation: Causing harm to reputation through false statements.
Trespass: Unlawful interference with a person, land, or goods.
Property Law: Covers rights and interests in both real property (land and buildings) and personal property. This includes laws on ownership, leases, mortgages, and intellectual property.
Family Law: Addresses matrimonial matters (marriage, divorce, judicial separation), child-related issues (custody, access, maintenance), and division of matrimonial assets. The Family Court handles these matters.
Company Law: Governs the formation, operation, governance, and dissolution of companies.
Insolvency Law: Deals with bankruptcy for individuals and winding-up procedures for companies unable to pay their debts.
Employment Law: Regulates the relationship between employers and employees, covering aspects like wages, working hours, termination, and discrimination.
Consumer Law: Protects consumer rights and promotes fair trading practices, including the Sale of Goods Ordinance and the Control of Exemption Clauses Ordinance.
Trusts Law: Deals with the creation and administration of trusts.
Wills and Succession Law: Governs the distribution of a person's estate after death, including rules for wills and intestacy (dying without a valid will).
Administrative Law: While primarily dealing with the powers of government bodies, it involves civil remedies like judicial review where citizens challenge the legality of government decisions.
Human Rights Law: The Basic Law and the Bill of Rights Ordinance (which localizes the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights) protect various civil rights and freedoms.
3. The Civil Justice System:
Hong Kong has an independent judiciary that presides over civil disputes. The court system is hierarchical:
Small Claims Tribunal: Handles small monetary claims up to HK$75,000, usually without legal representation, aiming for quick and informal resolution.
Labour Tribunal: Specializes in employment-related disputes.
Lands Tribunal: Deals with matters related to land, such as landlord and tenant disputes, compulsory sale for redevelopment, and compensation for land resumption.
Magistrates' Courts: While primarily dealing with criminal cases, they have limited civil jurisdiction in certain specific matters.
District Court: Has limited jurisdiction in civil matters, typically handling claims between HK75,000andHK3 million, and also matrimonial cases (Family Court is part of the District Court).
High Court: Comprises two divisions:
Court of First Instance: Has unlimited original jurisdiction in both civil and criminal matters. It hears larger and more complex civil cases, including commercial disputes, bankruptcy, company winding-up, and judicial review.
Court of Appeal: Hears appeals on civil and criminal matters from the Court of First Instance and the District Court.
Court of Final Appeal (CFA): The highest court in Hong Kong, with final adjudication power. It hears appeals from the Court of Appeal and ensures the consistent interpretation and application of the law, including the Basic Law. The CFA may include non-permanent judges from other common law jurisdictions.
Key Principles of Hong Kong's Civil Justice System:
Rule of Law: All individuals and the government are subject to the law, and legal power is derived from law.
Independence of the Judiciary: Judges are independent of the executive and legislative branches, ensuring impartial rulings.
Bilingualism: Both Chinese (Cantonese) and English are official languages, and court proceedings can be conducted in either or both.
Open Justice: Court hearings are generally open to the public, and judgments are published.
Emphasis on Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR): Mediation and arbitration are actively promoted as alternatives to litigation, particularly for commercial disputes. Hong Kong is a popular venue for international arbitration.
Despite the "One Country, Two Systems" framework, the legal landscape in Hong Kong has seen increasing influence from mainland China, particularly with the introduction of the National Security Law. However, the common law system, including its civil laws and independent judiciary, remains the foundation of Hong Kong's legal framework.
RELATED Blog
0 comments