Civil Laws at Bonaire (Netherlands)
Bonaire is one of the three Caribbean Netherlands islands (BES islands: Bonaire, Sint Eustatius, and Saba), which are special municipalities of the country of the Netherlands. As such, its legal system is a civil law system, fundamentally based on Dutch law.
The primary source of private law in Bonaire is the Civil Code BES (Burgerlijk Wetboek BES). This code, along with other laws that were largely taken over from the former Netherlands Antilles, is based on the comprehensive Dutch Civil Code.
Here's an overview of key areas of civil law in Bonaire:
1. General Legal Framework:
Civil Law System: Laws are primarily written and codified into a comprehensive, referable system.
Dutch Law: The legal system is based on Dutch law.
Official Language: Dutch is the official language for legal matters.
Joint Court of Justice: Bonaire falls under the jurisdiction of the Joint Court of Justice of Aruba, Curaçao, Sint Maarten, and of Bonaire, Sint Eustatius, and Saba. This court handles cases in the first instance through single-judge chambers (Courts of First Instance) and hears appeals through three-judge chambers.
Supreme Court of the Netherlands: Appellate decisions of the Joint Court of Justice are generally subject to appeals to the Supreme Court of the Netherlands (Hoge Raad der Nederlanden).
2. Family Law:
Family law in Bonaire is governed by the Civil Code BES and generally mirrors Dutch family law principles.
Marriage:
Minimum age for marriage is 18 years.
Same-sex marriage is legal in the Caribbean Netherlands. While the Netherlands (Europe) had already legalized it, the BES islands followed suit.
Couples can choose between community of property (where assets acquired during marriage are generally jointly owned) or a prenuptial agreement (Antenuptial agreement) to define separate property.
Cohabitation Agreements: Unmarried couples can formalize their relationship through cohabitation agreements (drawn up by a notary public) to regulate shared assets, debts, and provisions in case of separation or death. Without such an agreement, the law provides no automatic arrangements for cohabiting partners.
Divorce: Divorces are permitted and generally follow a procedure that allows for mutual consent or a court decision if contested.
Parental Responsibility and Child Custody:
Decisions are based on the best interests of the child.
Factors considered include parental fitness, the child's preference (if old enough to express it), and stability.
Joint parental responsibility is the general rule.
Child Support: Calculated based on the income of both parents and the needs of the child.
Adoption: Same-sex couples have the right to adopt children.
Paternity: Can be established through voluntary acknowledgment or genetic testing and court orders.
Domestic Violence: A serious offense punishable by law.
3. Property Law:
Property law in Bonaire largely follows Dutch principles, with key formal requirements.
Registration: Ownership of real estate in Bonaire must be recorded in the public register for real estate property (the Land Registry or Kadaster). This registry also provides an overview of encumbrances, mortgages, and liens.
Notarial Deed: The purchase and sale of registered property (real estate) must be executed by a notarial deed (a public deed drawn up by a notary public). This is a mandatory requirement for the legal transfer of ownership.
Foreign Ownership: There are generally no significant restrictions on foreign ownership of real estate in Bonaire. Foreigners can own property directly.
Housing Ordinance (Under Development): As of early 2025, Bonaire is actively working on a Housing Ordinance aimed at addressing the shortage of affordable homes. This includes discussions around:
Owner-occupancy requirements: Potentially obliging buyers to live in the house themselves for a certain period, to prevent speculative investment. This would likely apply to existing owner-occupied homes, not new construction, to encourage new housing stock.
Housing permits: Potentially requiring a permit for acquisition, especially for those without a "social connection" to the island.
These measures are still being elaborated and aim to prioritize residents and those with social ties to the island.
Leasehold: Long-term land leases are common and also need to be registered.
4. Contract Law:
Contract law in Bonaire is based on the Civil Code BES, reflecting the principle of freedom of contract while also providing protections.
Freedom of Contract: Parties have a great deal of freedom to determine the form and content of their agreements. Many rules in private law are regulatory, meaning they apply only if the parties have not made their own arrangements.
Essential Elements: For a valid contract, there must be:
Offer and Acceptance: A meeting of the minds.
Intention to Create Legal Relations: Parties must intend for their agreement to be legally binding.
Capacity: Parties must have the legal capacity to enter into a contract.
Legality of Purpose: The contract's object and purpose must be lawful.
Form: While many contracts can be oral, certain contracts (e.g., real estate purchase agreements) must be in writing and notarized to be legally enforceable and for official registration. Written contracts are generally recommended to avoid disputes.
Breach of Contract: If a party breaches a contract, the non-breaching party may be entitled to remedies such as damages, specific performance, or cancellation of the contract.
Consumer Protection: Rules exist to protect the economically weaker party in certain relationships, such as tenancy law and general terms and conditions, which may be annulled if unreasonably onerous.
5. Tort Law (Civil Liability):
Tort law in Bonaire, also derived from the Civil Code BES, deals with civil wrongs that cause harm, not arising from a contract.
Fault-Based Liability (Culpa): The general principle is that a person who causes damage to another through an unlawful act or omission, involving fault (negligence or intent), is obliged to compensate for the damage.
Elements typically include duty, breach of duty, causation, and harm.
Strict Liability: The law provides for strict liability in specific circumstances where fault does not need to be proven (e.g., liability for dangerous substances, certain animal damages, or product liability under specific conditions).
Damages: Compensation can cover both material (economic) damages and non-material (moral) damages, such as pain and suffering.
6. Inheritance Law:
Inheritance law in Bonaire is governed by the Civil Code BES and is closely aligned with Dutch inheritance law.
Sources of Succession: Succession can be based on a will (last will and testament) or by law (intestate succession) if no valid will exists.
Freedom of Testation with Restrictions: While individuals can make a will to determine the distribution of their assets, there are forced heirship rules that protect certain close relatives.
Children (or their descendants) have a legal right to a "legitimate portion" (legitieme portie), which is half of what they would have received under intestate succession. This limits the testator's ability to disinherit them completely.
Intestate Succession Order: If there is no will, the law dictates the order of heirs, typically prioritizing spouses and direct descendants, then parents and siblings, and so on.
Acceptance of Inheritance: Heirs have three options when an inheritance opens:
Unconditional Acceptance: Accepting all assets and all debts of the estate, even if debts exceed assets (personal liability).
Acceptance under the Privilege of Inventory (Beneficiary Acceptance): Accepting the inheritance, but limiting liability for debts to the value of the assets in the estate. This is often the safest option if the estate's financial health is uncertain. If one heir chooses this, the entire inheritance must be settled this way.
Rejection: Not accepting anything from the inheritance, which also means no liability for debts. This can have consequences for one's own children, who may then become heirs in their place.
Notary Public: A notary public plays a crucial role in inheritance matters, including drafting wills, preparing declarations of inheritance (which banks and institutions often require to confirm heirs and their acceptance method), and assisting with the settlement of estates.
No Inheritance Tax: As part of the Caribbean Netherlands, Bonaire generally does not levy inheritance tax.
Due to the nuances of local application and the connection to Dutch law, it is always advisable to consult with a qualified legal professional in Bonaire for specific civil law matters.
0 comments