Tort law at Mali
🇲🇱 Tort Law in Mali — Detailed Explanation with Case Studies
Mali’s civil liability system under the Civil Code focuses on wrongful acts (delicts) causing harm or injury to a person, property, or reputation, where the responsible party is required to compensate the victim. There are different grounds for tort claims in Mali, including negligence, intentional harm, and strict liability (when harm occurs without fault).
🟦 Case 1: Traffic Accident (Negligence and Personal Injury)
Situation:
A driver in Bamako causes an accident by failing to stop at a red light and collides with a pedestrian, causing serious injuries.
Legal issues:
Negligence: The driver’s failure to follow traffic laws could be considered negligent.
Duty of Care: Drivers have a duty to ensure the safety of pedestrians.
Damages: The injured pedestrian claims compensation for medical costs, pain, and suffering.
Legal outcome:
Under Article 1382 of the Civil Code, which governs liability for wrongful acts, the driver was found negligent. Mali courts typically hold that if harm occurs due to failure to meet a duty of care, compensation must be paid. In this case, the driver’s insurance was called upon to cover the pedestrian’s medical bills and compensation for pain.
🟦 Case 2: Animal Attack (Strict Liability)
Situation:
A person in Segou is attacked and injured by a neighbor’s dog that has been known to be aggressive.
Legal issues:
Strict Liability: In Mali, an animal owner can be held strictly liable for damage caused by their animal, even if there was no negligence.
Duty to Restrain Animals: Owners are expected to control their pets to avoid harm to others.
Personal Injury: The victim demands compensation for medical costs and emotional distress caused by the attack.
Legal outcome:
The neighbor was found strictly liable under Article 1384 of the Civil Code, which holds animal owners accountable for any harm their animals cause. The victim was awarded compensation for medical expenses, therapy, and other damages.
🟦 Case 3: Defamation (Damage to Reputation)
Situation:
A local journalist publishes false accusations about a businessman in Bamako, causing damage to his reputation and economic loss.
Legal issues:
Defamation: The businessman claims the journalist’s statements were false and harmed his reputation.
Reputation Damage: In Mali, defamation is both a civil and criminal offense, especially if it leads to economic or social harm.
Burden of Proof: The journalist must prove the truth of their statements to avoid liability.
Legal outcome:
The court found the journalist guilty of defamation under Article 1382 and Article 1383 of the Civil Code. Since the statements were not substantiated by facts, the businessman was awarded compensation for loss of business, social standing, and emotional harm caused by the defamation.
🟦 Case 4: Environmental Damage (Negligence & Property Damage)
Situation:
A mining company in the Kayes region dumps waste into a river, causing significant pollution and damage to the agricultural lands of nearby residents.
Legal issues:
Negligence: The company failed to take adequate measures to prevent environmental harm.
Duty of Care: Companies have an obligation to avoid harming the environment and surrounding communities.
Property Damage: The affected farmers claim compensation for loss of crops and damage to their land.
Legal outcome:
Under Article 1382 of the Civil Code, the court held the company liable for negligence. The mining company was ordered to pay compensation for the environmental damage, including the restoration of the agricultural land, and to cover the financial losses of the affected residents.
🟦 Case 5: Medical Malpractice (Negligence & Professional Liability)
Situation:
A patient in a Bamako hospital undergoes surgery, but due to the surgeon’s negligence, a surgical instrument is left inside the body, leading to a severe infection.
Legal issues:
Medical Negligence: The surgeon failed to meet the standard of care expected in their profession, leading to harm.
Professional Liability: Medical professionals are held to a high standard of care, and failure to adhere to these standards can result in tort claims.
Compensation: The patient seeks compensation for additional medical costs, pain, suffering, and long-term health issues.
Legal outcome:
Under Article 1382 of the Civil Code, the surgeon was held liable for the malpractice, as leaving a surgical instrument inside a patient is a clear case of negligence. The hospital was also found liable for the surgeon's actions, and the patient was awarded compensation for additional treatment, lost wages, and suffering.
🟦 Case 6: Consumer Protection (Product Liability)
Situation:
A consumer purchases a defective electrical appliance from a store in Mopti. The appliance catches fire, causing damage to the consumer’s home.
Legal issues:
Product Defect: The manufacturer is responsible for ensuring their products are safe for use.
Consumer Protection: Malian consumer laws protect buyers from defective products and require compensation for damages caused by unsafe products.
Strict Liability: The manufacturer can be held strictly liable for defects in their products, even if they were unaware of the fault.
Legal outcome:
The court found the manufacturer strictly liable for the fire caused by the defective appliance under Article 1384 of the Civil Code, which holds sellers and manufacturers accountable for harm caused by their products. The consumer was awarded compensation for the destruction of their home, as well as the costs of replacing the damaged property.
🟦 Summary of Tort Law Principles in Mali
| Area of Law | Key Principle | Key Legal Text | Relevant Articles |
|---|---|---|---|
| Negligence | Duty of care | Civil Code (C.O.C.C.) | Articles 1382-1383 |
| Strict Liability | Liability without fault | Civil Code (C.O.C.C.) | Articles 1384 |
| Defamation | Damage to reputation | Penal Code, Civil Code | Articles 1382, 1383 |
| Medical Malpractice | Negligence in profession | Civil Code (C.O.C.C.) | Article 1382 |
| Product Liability | Defective products | Civil Code (C.O.C.C.) | Articles 1384 |
Conclusion:
In Mali, tort law involves holding individuals or entities accountable for harm caused to others, whether through negligence, intentional misconduct, or strict liability. The principles of tort law are grounded in civil liability, and while specific tort cases are handled by civil courts, some cases also have criminal implications (e.g., defamation, medical malpractice).
RELATED Blog
comments