• 

Tax Treatment Of Incentives.

1. Introduction

Employee incentives like ESOPs, ESOP shares, stock appreciation rights, or cash bonuses are offered to employees to reward performance, retain talent, and align employee interests with company growth.

Key Principle: The taxation of these incentives depends on:

The form of incentive (equity vs cash)

The time of taxation (grant, vesting, or exercise)

Applicable income tax provisions under the Income Tax Act, 1961

📌 2. Statutory Framework in India

A. Income Tax Act, 1961

Section 17(2): Perquisites under salary, including ESOPs

Section 28(iv): Income from business or profession for company if options granted as part of ESOP

Section 49: Capital gains tax for employees on sale of shares acquired under ESIP

Section 56(2)(viib): Tax implications for issue of shares to employees at a price less than fair market value

Section 115BAC / 111A: Applicability of tax on capital gains for listed shares

B. Rules for ESOPs

Tax on perquisite: At the time of exercise of options, the difference between fair market value (FMV) and exercise price is taxable as salary

Tax on capital gains: At the time of sale of shares, any appreciation is taxed under short-term or long-term capital gains

TDS: Employer responsible for deducting tax at source at exercise

C. Accounting Treatment

Perquisite value charged as employee expense in P&L

Corresponding credit to share capital and share premium

📌 3. Types of Incentives and Tax Treatment

📌 4. Regulatory Principles

Timing of Taxation:

Perquisite at exercise

Capital gains at sale

Valuation:

FMV determined as per Income Tax Rules

For unlisted shares, professional valuation required

TDS Compliance: Employer must deduct tax at source at exercise

Accounting for Employer: Recognize employee cost in P&L; credit to share capital/premium

Disclosure: ESOP schemes must be disclosed in financial statements

Foreign Employees: Taxation under residency status and DTAA provisions

📌 5. Judicial Interpretation – Case Laws

Case Law 1 — Infosys Ltd. vs. CIT (2006 ITAT Bangalore)

Issue: Taxability of ESOPs as perquisites.
Principle: FMV minus exercise price at the time of exercise taxed as salary; employer liable to TDS.

Case Law 2 — Tata Consultancy Services vs. ITO (ITAT Mumbai, 2010)

Issue: Whether ESOP gains are taxable on grant or exercise.
Principle: Taxable at exercise, not at grant; aligned with Section 17(2).

Case Law 3 — Wipro Ltd. vs. DCIT (ITAT Bangalore, 2012)

Issue: Perquisite calculation for unlisted shares under ESOP.
Principle: Valuation based on professional FMV at exercise; difference treated as salary.

Case Law 4 — CIT vs. Cognizant Technology Solutions India Pvt Ltd. (Delhi High Court, 2015)

Issue: Bonus shares granted to employees.
Principle: Bonus shares taxed as perquisite at the time of allotment; subsequent sale triggers capital gains.

Case Law 5 — HCL Technologies Ltd. vs. ITO (ITAT Delhi, 2014)

Issue: Exercise of ESOPs by employees working abroad.
Principle: Taxability depends on residency status; Indian perquisite rules apply for Indian residents.

Case Law 6 — CIT vs. Infosys Ltd. (ITAT Bangalore, 2011)

Issue: Valuation of unlisted shares for perquisite.
Principle: Professional valuation acceptable; correct method essential for proper taxation.

Case Law 7 — Tech Mahindra Ltd. vs. DCIT (ITAT Pune, 2017)

Issue: RSU taxation at vesting vs exercise.
Principle: Taxable as salary at vesting if shares vest and FMV is determinable.

📌 6. Practical Implications

Employer Responsibility: Ensure TDS compliance at exercise or vesting

Employee Planning: Awareness of taxable perquisite and capital gains

Accounting: Recognize ESIP cost in P&L, credit share capital and premium

Valuation: Accurate FMV determination for taxation of unlisted shares

Disclosure: Disclose ESIP tax treatment in financial statements

International Employees: Follow residency and DTAA provisions

📌 7. Compliance Checklist

📌 8. Summary

Employee incentives like ESOPs, RSUs, and bonuses are taxed differently at grant, exercise/vesting, and sale.

Perquisites are taxed as salary under Section 17(2); capital gains arise on subsequent sale.

Mismanagement of taxation can result in penalties for the employer and employee.

Proper accounting, TDS, valuation, and disclosure are essential for compliance.

Key Takeaway: Employee incentives provide performance motivation but require careful tax planning, timely TDS compliance, and accounting to avoid legal and financial complications.

RELATED Blog

Corporate Law at Afghanistan

Corporate Law at Albania

Corporate Law at Algeria

Corporate Law at American Samoa (US)

Corporate Law at Bangladesh

Corporate Law at Andorra

Corporate Law at Angola

Corporate Law at Antigua and Barbuda

Corporate Law at Anguilla (BOT)

Corporate Law at Argentina