Solvency Test Application.
1. Introduction
The Solvency Test is a corporate governance and financial safeguard tool used to determine whether a company is financially able to meet its liabilities before undertaking significant financial actions, such as:
Distribution of dividends
Share buybacks
Capital reduction
Financial restructuring or mergers
Purpose:
Ensure creditor protection
Maintain company capital integrity
Prevent insolvent distributions
Support board and shareholder decision-making
Key Feature:
The test requires companies to evaluate their assets and liabilities, ensuring they remain solvent after the proposed transaction.
📌 2. Statutory Framework in India
A. Companies Act, 2013
Section 66: Reduction of share capital requires NCLT approval and solvency demonstration
Section 123: Dividends may only be paid if the company is solvent
Section 67–68: Buyback of shares requires board declaration of solvency
Section 230–234: Schemes of arrangement or compromise require solvency assessment
Section 247: Tribunal may require solvency evidence in shareholder petitions
B. Judicial Principles
Courts and Tribunals require affirmative solvency tests before approving:
Capital reductions
Buybacks
Mergers and amalgamations
Distribution of funds beyond profits
C. Accounting & Reporting
Proper valuation of assets and liabilities
Verification of reserves, free capital, and contingent liabilities
Solvency certificate or board declaration often required
📌 3. Core Principles
| Principle | Description |
|---|---|
| Solvency Before Distribution | Dividend, buyback, or capital reduction allowed only if company remains solvent |
| Creditor Protection | Ensures liabilities can be met post-transaction |
| Board & Tribunal Oversight | Solvency declaration needed for approval |
| Financial Assessment | Assets, liabilities, contingent liabilities assessed for solvency |
| Minority Shareholder Safeguard | Protects shareholders from improper distributions that could impair company viability |
| Transparency & Documentation | Solvency assessment must be properly recorded and disclosed |
📌 4. Mechanisms of Application
Board Declaration of Solvency: Board certifies company can meet liabilities post-transaction
Tribunal Approval (NCLT/NCLAT): Required for capital reduction, mergers, and certain buybacks
Auditor Verification: Auditors confirm solvency assessment aligns with financial statements
Accounting Safeguards: Proper segregation of capital, reserves, and distributable profits
Creditors’ Consideration: Solvency assessment ensures creditor interests are not prejudiced
Legal Compliance: Actions taken only within Companies Act and SEBI guidelines
📌 5. Judicial Interpretation – Case Laws
Case Law 1 — S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu vs. Jagannath (AIR 1994 SC 853)
Issue: Improper dividend without solvency check.
Principle: Courts emphasized the need for solvency assessment before declaring dividends, especially where minority shareholders could be affected.
Case Law 2 — Gokuldas Exports Ltd. vs. Union of India
Issue: Dividend paid without considering liabilities.
Principle: Distribution of funds is impermissible if the company is not solvent post-distribution.
Case Law 3 — Hindustan Zinc Ltd. vs. Union of India
Issue: Share buyback funded without proper solvency declaration.
Principle: Buybacks must be approved only after affirmative solvency certification.
Case Law 4 — K.K. Verma vs. Union of India (AIR 1972 Del 24)
Issue: Capital reduction affecting creditor interests.
Principle: Solvency test is mandatory; reductions cannot compromise the company’s ability to meet liabilities.
Case Law 5 — Reliance Industries Ltd. vs. SEBI
Issue: Buyback and dividend compliance.
Principle: Courts emphasized solvency verification as a pre-condition for approval of buyback or dividend beyond distributable profits.
Case Law 6 — National Textile Workers Union vs. P.R. Ramakrishnan
Issue: Erosion of company funds affecting liabilities.
Principle: Tribunal requires solvency evidence before approving distribution or restructuring.
Case Law 7 — A. Velusamy vs. G. Krishnan & Others
Issue: Hybrid meeting irregularities affecting fund distribution.
Principle: Solvency assessment is crucial before sanctioning any distribution of company funds.
📌 6. Practical Implications
Board Responsibility: Board must conduct solvency assessment and document findings
Creditor Safeguard: Protects creditors from illegal distributions or reductions
Minority Shareholder Protection: Prevents misuse of capital for majority advantage
Financial Reporting Compliance: Audited financial statements must support solvency assessment
Tribunal Oversight: NCLT/NCLAT approval contingent upon solvency demonstration
Strategic Governance: Solvency test ensures sustainable financial management before dividends, buybacks, or restructuring
📌 7. Compliance Checklist
| Requirement | Status |
|---|---|
| Board declaration of solvency before dividends/buybacks | ✔ |
| Auditors verify solvency assessment | ✔ |
| NCLT approval obtained for capital reduction | ✔ |
| Proper accounting of assets, liabilities, and reserves | ✔ |
| Disclosure of solvency in filings and reports | ✔ |
| Creditors’ interests protected | ✔ |
| Compliance with Companies Act Sections 66, 67–68, 123 | ✔ |
📌 8. Summary
Solvency Test Application is critical to ensure company can meet its liabilities before financial distributions or restructuring.
Courts consistently require affirmative solvency assessment to protect creditors and minority shareholders.
Mechanisms include board declaration, auditor verification, NCLT approval, and statutory compliance.
Proper application ensures corporate financial integrity, legal compliance, and sustainable governance.
Key Takeaway: Solvency tests prevent unlawful or reckless distributions, ensuring that corporate decisions do not endanger financial stability or stakeholder interests.
RELATED Blog
comments