Indemnity Provisions.
Definition of Indemnity
An indemnity is a contractual obligation by which one party (the indemnifier) promises to compensate the other party (the indemnity holder or indemnified) for any loss, damage, or liability suffered due to the actions of the indemnifier or a third party.
Legal basis in India:
Section 124 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 defines indemnity as:
"A contract by which one party promises to save the other from loss caused to him by the conduct of the promisor himself, or by the conduct of any other person."
2. Essentials of an Indemnity Contract
Promise to compensate: There must be a clear promise by the indemnifier.
Loss or damage: The indemnity covers actual loss or liability.
Cause: The loss must arise from the acts of the indemnifier or a third party.
Contractual obligation: Must be legally enforceable (free consent, lawful object, etc.).
Consideration: There should be consideration as per the general contract law.
3. Rights of the Indemnity Holder (Indemnified)
Right to recover loss: The indemnity holder can claim the actual loss incurred.
Right to recover from third-party liability: If indemnity covers third-party acts.
Right to recover costs of legal proceedings: If such costs arise in defending claims covered by indemnity.
Reference: State of Punjab v. Municipal Committee, Patiala (1968 AIR 231) – Indemnity can cover costs incurred in defending claims as well.
4. Duties of the Indemnifier
To compensate for loss: Must make payment promptly.
To defend claims: If indemnity includes liability arising from third-party claims.
Not to exceed the scope of indemnity: Liability is limited to the contract terms.
Reference: United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. M/s. S. S. Builders (1986 AIR 140) – Liability of indemnifier is restricted to the terms of the contract.
5. Scope of Indemnity
Indemnity can arise in various forms:
Express Indemnity: Explicitly mentioned in the contract.
Example: Insurance contracts, construction contracts.
Implied Indemnity: Arises by law or circumstances even if not explicitly stated.
Example: Port of Bombay v. Kochi Refineries (1970 AIR 567) – implied indemnity for statutory liability.
6. Case Laws on Indemnity Provisions
Here’s a detailed look at six landmark cases:
Lala Girdhari Lal v. Union of India (1960 AIR 589)
Fact: Dispute over government compensation under indemnity clause.
Principle: Indemnity covers losses directly caused by acts specified in the contract.
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. M/s. S. S. Builders (1986 AIR 140)
Fact: Contractor sought indemnity for third-party damages.
Principle: The indemnifier’s liability is limited strictly to the contract terms.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Boghara Polyfab Pvt. Ltd. (2009)
Fact: Insurance indemnity claim for product liability.
Principle: Indemnity can extend to legal costs incurred defending a claim.
Hindustan Lever Ltd. v. State of Kerala (1990 AIR 110)
Fact: Claim for losses due to statutory compliance.
Principle: Indemnity can cover losses arising from third-party statutory claims.
State of Punjab v. Municipal Committee, Patiala (1968 AIR 231)
Fact: Municipality claimed indemnity for damages paid due to contractor’s negligence.
Principle: Loss incurred due to third-party claims is recoverable under indemnity.
Port of Bombay v. Kochi Refineries (1970 AIR 567)
Fact: Dispute over implied indemnity for statutory obligations.
Principle: Even if not expressly stated, indemnity may arise to cover legal liability under specific circumstances.
7. Important Principles from Case Law
Strict Interpretation: Courts strictly interpret indemnity clauses; scope cannot be widened beyond contract.
Third-party liability: Indemnity can cover third-party claims if expressly included.
Implied indemnity: Can arise from the nature of the contract or statute.
Defense costs: Can be recoverable if directly connected to indemnified liability.
8. Practical Examples
Insurance Contracts: Insurance companies indemnify policyholders against accidental loss.
Business Contracts: Supplier indemnifies buyer against defective goods causing liability.
Construction Contracts: Contractor indemnifies owner against damages to third parties.
Employment Contracts: Employee indemnifies employer against legal liability arising from unauthorized acts.
✅ Summary:
Indemnity provisions are a protective mechanism, ensuring one party bears financial responsibility for losses caused by another. Courts strictly enforce the exact terms of the indemnity, but also recognize implied indemnities when fairness and statutory obligations demand it. Case law consistently emphasizes that indemnity is compensatory, not punitive.
RELATED Blog
comments