Green Channel Mergers Framework
Green Channel Mergers Framework (India)
1. Legal Basis
Introduced under:
Competition Act, 2002 (Sections 5 & 6)
Competition Commission of India (Combination) Regulations, 2011
Regulation 5A (Green Channel Route) — inserted in 2019
It provides automatic approval for combinations that pose no risk to competition.
2. Objective
To:
Reduce regulatory burden
Speed up non-problematic mergers
Allow CCI to focus on complex cases
Under this route, approval is deemed granted immediately upon filing.
3. Eligibility Conditions
A combination qualifies only if:
No Horizontal Overlap
Parties must not produce/provide identical or substitutable goods/services.
No Vertical Relationship
No buyer-seller relationship between the parties.
No Complementary Link
Products/services should not be related in a way that complements each other.
This must be true for:
The parties
Their group entities
Controlled entities
Even indirect overlaps disqualify.
4. Self-Assessment Requirement
Parties must file:
Form I under Green Channel
A declaration of no overlaps
If declaration is false, approval is void ab initio.
5. When Green Channel Cannot Be Used
| Situation | Reason |
|---|---|
| Horizontal competitors | Potential market power |
| Vertical supply link | Risk of foreclosure |
| Complementary products | Leveraging risk |
| Complex multi-product groups | Risk of indirect overlaps |
6. Legal Consequences of Wrong Use
If parties wrongly claim eligibility:
Approval becomes invalid
Transaction treated as not notified
Penalties for gun jumping
7. Important Case Laws & Decisions
Case 1: Adani Green Energy Ltd. Acquisition (2020, CCI)
Facts: Renewable energy asset acquisition.
Outcome: Cleared under Green Channel.
Principle: Pure asset acquisition without overlaps qualifies.
Case 2: Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation Transaction (CCI)
Facts: Financial services investment with no Indian overlap.
Outcome: Green Channel approval.
Principle: Financial investor transactions often qualify.
Case 3: Temasek Holdings Investment Case (CCI)
Facts: Minority stake acquisition in non-overlapping sector.
Outcome: Approved via Green Channel.
Principle: Minority investments with no control overlaps eligible.
Case 4: Alpha TC Holdings Pte Ltd. Combination (CCI)
Facts: Offshore transaction with Indian nexus but no overlaps.
Outcome: Cleared automatically.
Principle: Global deals can use Green Channel if no overlaps in India.
Case 5: PI Opportunities Fund Case (CCI)
Facts: Investment in enterprise outside investor’s operational market.
Outcome: Green Channel clearance.
Principle: Private equity investments are common users.
Case 6: CCI Order on Invalidation of Green Channel Declaration (2021)
Facts: Parties incorrectly claimed no overlaps.
Held: Approval void; treated as non-notified combination.
Principle: Strict liability for false declaration.
Case 7: Tata Group Internal Restructuring Case (CCI)
Facts: Intra-group restructuring with no market impact.
Outcome: Cleared under Green Channel.
Principle: Non-competitive restructurings benefit from fast-track.
8. Comparison: Normal vs Green Channel
| Feature | Normal Route | Green Channel |
|---|---|---|
| Review time | 30–210 days | Immediate approval |
| CCI analysis | Yes | No prior review |
| Overlaps allowed | Yes | No |
| Risk of investigation | During review | Only if declaration false |
| Certainty | Post approval | Immediate but risky if wrong |
9. Key Legal Principles
| Principle | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Automatic approval | Upon filing |
| Zero overlap requirement | Strict standard |
| Self-certification | Parties bear responsibility |
| Approval void if misused | Severe consequence |
| Designed for low-risk mergers | Not for market-sensitive deals |
| Encourages ease of doing business | Regulatory efficiency |
Conclusion
The Green Channel is essentially a:
“Trust-based fast track” for non-problematic mergers
It works only where no competitive link exists between the parties. It dramatically reduces approval time but places full legal risk on the parties.
RELATED Blog
comments