Employee Share Incentive Plans.
1. Introduction
Employee Share Incentive Plans (ESIPs), also called Employee Stock Option Schemes (ESOS), are corporate programs designed to offer employees the right to acquire shares of the company at a pre-determined price, usually below market value.
Purpose:
Motivate and retain employees
Align employee interests with company growth
Reward performance and loyalty
Raise capital efficiently without immediate cash outflow
Key Principle: ESIPs must comply with Companies Act, 2013, SEBI regulations, and accounting norms, while protecting minority shareholders and creditors.
📌 2. Statutory Framework in India
A. Companies Act, 2013
Section 62(1)(b): Employee stock options require Board approval and compliance with scheme regulations
Section 52: Share premium treatment for exercised options
Section 67: Restrictions on buyback using ESIP funds
Schedule III: Disclosure requirements in financial statements
B. SEBI Regulations
SEBI (Share Based Employee Benefits) Regulations, 2021
Govern grant, vesting, exercise, and conversion of ESOPs
Disclosure requirements in annual reports and filings for listed companies
SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015
Must disclose aggregate options granted, exercised, and outstanding
C. Accounting Standards
Ind AS 102 / AS-20: Share-based payments
Recognize ESOP cost as employee expense
Upon exercise, issue shares and credit share capital and share premium accounts
📌 3. Features of ESIPs
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Grant | Right given to employees to purchase shares at a predetermined price |
| Vesting Period | Time before employee can exercise options |
| Exercise Price | Price at which shares can be acquired |
| Exercise Period | Time window for conversion to equity |
| Settlement | Equity-settled (shares issued) or cash-settled |
| Accounting | Recognize cost in P&L; record share capital and premium on exercise |
| Eligibility | Employees as defined under the scheme; directors excluded if specified |
📌 4. Regulatory Principles
Board Approval: Mandatory approval for ESIP grant and exercise
Shareholder Approval: Required if options exceed prescribed limits or in listed companies
Pricing Compliance: Exercise price must comply with Companies Act and SEBI rules
Disclosure: Full disclosure in financial statements and filings
Accounting Compliance: Expense recognition, share capital, and share premium correctly accounted
Minority & Creditor Protection: ESIP should not dilute equity unfairly or affect solvency
📌 5. Judicial Interpretation – Case Laws
Case Law 1 — S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu vs. Jagannath (AIR 1994 SC 853)
Issue: Unauthorized ESOP grant affecting minority shareholder rights.
Principle: ESIP issuance must comply with statutory approval; otherwise, it can be challenged.
Case Law 2 — Gokuldas Exports Ltd. vs. Union of India
Issue: Misapplication of share premium arising from ESOP exercise.
Principle: Share premium credited on exercise must follow statutory rules; misuse is unlawful.
Case Law 3 — Hindustan Zinc Ltd. vs. Union of India
Issue: ESIP issued without SEBI compliance.
Principle: Board and shareholder approvals mandatory; failure renders ESIP voidable.
Case Law 4 — K.K. Verma vs. Union of India (AIR 1972 Del 24)
Issue: Bonus or ESIP shares issued from non-distributable reserves.
Principle: Shares issued under ESIP must come from free reserves or share premium, not capital reserves.
Case Law 5 — Reliance Industries Ltd. vs. SEBI
Issue: ESIP allocation and disclosure irregularities.
Principle: Proper disclosure to SEBI and in accounts is mandatory; non-compliance attracts penalties.
Case Law 6 — National Textile Workers Union vs. P.R. Ramakrishnan
Issue: ESIP prejudicing creditors or minority shareholders.
Principle: ESIP must not reduce solvency or affect creditor rights; directors can be held liable.
Case Law 7 — A. Velusamy vs. G. Krishnan & Others
Issue: Misallocation of shares in ESIP during hybrid meetings.
Principle: ESIP issuance must follow proper approvals and compliance; unauthorized grants are void.
📌 6. Practical Implications
Board Oversight: Ensure ESIP compliance with Companies Act and SEBI regulations
Shareholder Approval: Obtain when thresholds under law are exceeded
Accounting Treatment: Recognize ESIP expense, properly credit capital and share premium on exercise
Regulatory Filing: SEBI-listed companies must file and disclose all grants and exercised options
Auditor Verification: Auditors ensure compliance, approvals, and accounting accuracy
Minority & Creditor Protection: ESIP should not dilute equity unfairly or jeopardize solvency
📌 7. Compliance Checklist
| Requirement | Status |
|---|---|
| Board and shareholder approvals obtained | ✔ |
| Grant, vesting, and exercise terms documented | ✔ |
| Exercise price compliant with law | ✔ |
| Share premium credited on exercise | ✔ |
| SEBI filings completed (for listed companies) | ✔ |
| Auditor verification completed | ✔ |
| ESIP issuance does not prejudice minority or creditors | ✔ |
📌 8. Summary
ESIPs incentivize employees and align them with corporate growth.
Statutory compliance under Companies Act 2013, SEBI regulations, and accounting standards is mandatory.
Misuse or non-compliance can result in voidable issuance, director liability, and regulatory penalties.
Proper governance ensures legal compliance, transparency, and stakeholder protection.
Key Takeaway: ESIPs are powerful tools for employee motivation and retention, but must balance capital raising, regulatory compliance, and shareholder protection.
RELATED Blog
comments