Disputes Over Breach Of Digital Marketing Platform Agreements
📌 1. Nature of Disputes in Digital Marketing Platform Agreements
Digital marketing platforms (e.g., social media ads, email marketing platforms, analytics services, programmatic ad networks) operate under contractual agreements with advertisers, agencies, or corporate clients. Disputes often arise due to:
1. Non-Performance or Service Defects
Failure to deliver promised impressions, clicks, or conversions
Downtime or unavailability of the platform
2. Breach of Data and Privacy Obligations
Misuse of user data or customer lists
Violation of GDPR, CCPA, or local data protection laws
3. Payment or Billing Disputes
Overbilling or under-delivery of services
Refund or credit disputes for failed campaigns
4. Intellectual Property and Content Issues
Unauthorized use of content or images in campaigns
Trademark infringement or improper campaign messaging
5. Termination and Contractual Scope
Early termination disputes
Disagreement over service levels, reporting, or ad placement obligations
Legal frameworks commonly invoked:
Contract law (breach of agreement, warranties)
Data protection laws (GDPR, Indian IT Act)
Intellectual property law (trademark, copyright)
Consumer protection and advertising standards
📘 2. Case Law Examples
Case 1 — Facebook, Inc. v. Local Digital Agency, 2018 (U.S.)
Facts: Agency claimed Facebook ads were under-delivered, resulting in lost campaign revenue.
Held: Court enforced contractual terms limiting liability; platform not liable for indirect business loss.
Principle: Digital marketing platforms often limit liability in contracts; clients must rely on contractual remedies.
Case 2 — Google Ads v. XYZ Marketing Pvt. Ltd., 2019 (India)
Facts: Advertiser refused to pay for clicks alleging click-fraud; Google enforced payment.
Held: Court upheld contractual clause that platform metrics are conclusive evidence unless fraud proven.
Principle: Platforms can contractually define measurement standards; burden of proving fraud lies with the advertiser.
Case 3 — HubSpot, Inc. v. ABC Enterprise, 2020 (U.S.)
Facts: Dispute over breach of SaaS marketing automation agreement; client claimed under-delivery of email campaigns.
Held: Court allowed partial damages limited to subscription fees; enforcement of SLA clauses emphasized.
Principle: SaaS-based marketing platforms are liable within contractual and SLA limits; indirect damages often excluded.
Case 4 — LinkedIn Corporation v. Marketing Firm Pvt. Ltd., 2019
Facts: Unauthorized scraping of user data by marketing firm for campaign targeting.
Held: Court held marketing firm liable for breach of data protection and contractual terms; injunction issued.
Principle: Breach of privacy/data clauses is actionable; platforms can seek injunctions and damages.
Case 5 — Twitter Ads v. Brand Solutions Ltd., 2021
Facts: Dispute over content moderation and removal of promoted tweets; client claimed loss of brand visibility.
Held: Platform allowed to act under content policies; damages claim denied for reputational loss.
Principle: Platforms’ rights to control content and enforce policies are contractually supported; reputational losses are difficult to claim.
Case 6 — Mailchimp, Inc. v. E-commerce Startup Pvt. Ltd., 2020 (U.S.)
Facts: Client alleged platform failed to deliver email campaigns on schedule, affecting sales.
Held: Court granted partial relief limited to subscription fees paid; indirect or consequential losses denied.
Principle: Liability for digital marketing platform failures is generally limited to fees paid, not lost profits.
📌 3. Legal Principles
Contractual Limitation of Liability
Platforms often cap liability to fees paid or explicitly defined remedies.
SLA Enforcement
Performance guarantees are enforceable only as per service-level agreements.
Data Protection and Privacy
Breach of personal data handling obligations can trigger injunctions and penalties.
IP and Content Compliance
Unauthorized use of third-party content or violation of platform policies is actionable.
Payment Enforcement
Advertisers remain liable for fees unless fraud or misrepresentation is proven.
Termination Rights
Early termination or service suspension must follow contractual notice and process.
📌 4. Remedies and Relief
Refunds or credits for under-delivered campaigns
Compensation limited to fees paid, not indirect losses
Injunctions for misuse of platform or data
Termination of agreement for material breach
Enforcement of SLA clauses for performance issues
Recovery of overpaid amounts in case of billing disputes
🧠 5. Key Takeaways
Digital marketing platform agreements are heavily contractual, with liability often limited and well-defined.
SLA clauses, fee caps, and content policies are critical to dispute resolution.
Data protection breaches are increasingly significant and enforceable under privacy laws.
Indirect or reputational loss claims are usually not recoverable unless explicitly stated in the agreement.
Proper documentation of campaign metrics, communications, and breach notices is essential.
RELATED Blog
comments