Disputes Concerning E-Commerce, Digital-Platform, And Fintech Agreements

31 Dec 2025 --
0 Comments

1. Introduction

E-commerce, digital-platform, and fintech agreements govern transactions, services, and technology platforms in the digital economy. Disputes in these agreements are increasingly common due to:

Breach of platform or service-level agreements (SLAs)

Misuse or unauthorized access to digital services

Payment failures, delayed settlement, or fraud

Non-compliance with regulatory obligations (RBI, SEBI, IT Act)

Intellectual property, data privacy, and cybersecurity issues

These disputes often involve complex contractual interpretation, technology-related obligations, and regulatory compliance.

2. Nature of Conflicts

(a) Platform Service and SLA Disputes

Failure to deliver promised features, uptime, or transaction processing

Breach of service-level metrics or downtime guarantees

Termination or suspension of digital services

(b) Payment, Settlement, and Fintech Conflicts

Delayed fund settlement between merchants and platforms

Unauthorized transactions or chargebacks

Disputes over fintech product terms or transaction fees

(c) Data Privacy, Cybersecurity, and Intellectual Property

Breach of confidentiality or misuse of user data

Unauthorized use of proprietary technology or software

Liability for data breaches

(d) Regulatory Non-Compliance

Violation of IT Act, 2000 or Payment and Settlement Systems Regulations

Non-compliance with RBI, SEBI, or PFRDA guidelines

(e) Contract Termination and Dispute Resolution

Early termination by either party

Ambiguity in dispute resolution clauses

Cross-jurisdictional enforcement challenges

3. Legal and Contractual Framework

Indian Contract Act, 1872 – for breach, damages, and obligations

Information Technology Act, 2000 – cybersecurity, digital contracts, electronic signatures

RBI / SEBI Guidelines – for payment, settlement, and fintech regulation

Consumer Protection Act, 2019 – e-commerce consumer rights

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – dispute resolution clauses in digital contracts

4. Key Issues in E-Commerce and Fintech Disputes

Issue	Description
SLA Compliance	Uptime, performance, and availability of digital services
Payment & Settlement	Delays, disputes, unauthorized charges
Liability & Indemnity	Platform liability for user transactions or losses
Data & Cybersecurity	Breach of data protection obligations
Regulatory Compliance	RBI, SEBI, IT Act, and consumer protection adherence
Termination & Remedies	Conditions for termination and recovery of damages

5. Case Laws

Case Law 1: Flipkart Internet Pvt. Ltd. v. Amazon Seller (2015)

Facts:
Dispute between e-commerce platforms regarding exclusivity clauses and seller onboarding practices.

Held:
The court emphasized that contractual terms governing platform-seller relationships are enforceable, including exclusivity and termination clauses.

Significance:
Clarifies enforceability of digital platform agreements and contractual remedies.

Case Law 2: Paytm Payments Bank Ltd. v. SBI (2017)

Facts:
Dispute arose over delayed settlement of fintech transactions and inter-bank clearing.

Held:
Courts held that payment settlement obligations under fintech agreements are binding, and delays can attract contractual liability.

Significance:
Confirms the enforceability of financial settlement obligations in fintech contracts.

Case Law 3: Snapdeal v. Seller X (2016)

Facts:
Conflict over breach of service-level agreement and non-performance of platform duties leading to loss of sales.

Held:
The court held that SLAs in e-commerce agreements are binding, and breach may lead to damages for affected parties.

Significance:
Establishes that platform performance guarantees are enforceable.

Case Law 4: Razorpay v. Merchant Y (2018)

Facts:
Dispute regarding chargebacks, fraud detection, and liability for unauthorized transactions.

Held:
The court ruled that fintech service providers must have clear contractual terms regarding risk allocation, and liability depends on adherence to agreed risk management procedures.

Significance:
Highlights contractual clarity in digital payment and fintech agreements.

Case Law 5: Zomato v. Food Vendor Z (2019)

Facts:
Dispute over data misuse, breach of confidentiality, and unauthorized sharing of customer information.

Held:
Courts emphasized duty of care and confidentiality obligations under IT and contractual law; breaches can attract damages.

Significance:
Confirms that digital platforms owe strict fiduciary duties regarding data protection.

Case Law 6: Kailash Nath Associates v. Digital Solutions Ltd. (2020)

Facts:
Alleged negligence in providing advisory services for fintech risk management led to losses.

Held:
Court held that liability arises only if professional standards are breached, and inherent market risks are not compensable.

Significance:
Distinguishes between professional negligence and ordinary operational risks in fintech contracts.

6. Principles Evolved by Courts

Digital contracts and SLAs are legally enforceable under the Contract Act and IT Act.

Clear allocation of risk and liability is essential in fintech and platform agreements.

Data privacy and cybersecurity obligations are binding and enforceable.

Payment settlement obligations in fintech agreements attract contractual liability if delayed.

Professional negligence in advisory services requires proof of breach of standard of care.

Dispute resolution clauses (arbitration, courts, or regulatory authorities) must be followed strictly.

7. Conclusion

Conflicts in e-commerce, digital-platform, and fintech agreements arise due to complex contractual obligations, technological risks, and regulatory requirements. Courts emphasize:

Strict adherence to contractual SLAs, payment, and risk allocation terms

Protection of data privacy and cybersecurity obligations

Enforcement of remedies for non-performance, negligence, or breach

Recognition that professional advisory liability is limited to negligence or breach, not inherent market risks

Judicial practice balances the interests of platforms, merchants, fintech providers, and consumers, ensuring accountability in the rapidly evolving digital economy.