Climate Risk Disclosures.
Climate Risk Disclosures
Definition:
Climate risk disclosure is the reporting of financial and non-financial risks and opportunities related to climate change. It informs investors, regulators, and stakeholders about a company’s exposure to climate-related physical, transitional, and regulatory risks, and the strategies to mitigate them.
1. Legal and Regulatory Framework
Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD)
Voluntary global framework providing guidance on:
Governance
Strategy
Risk management
Metrics and targets
Increasingly adopted by regulators to standardize climate risk reporting.
EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) & ESRS
Requires large and listed EU companies to disclose climate-related risks and impacts.
Focus on double materiality:
How climate affects the company.
How the company affects the environment and society.
Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI)
BRSR mandates disclosure of climate-related risk policies, mitigation strategies, and performance metrics.
Companies Act, 2013 (India)
Section 134(3)(n): Directors’ report must disclose principal risks, which includes climate and environmental risks for applicable companies.
International Standards
GRI 305 (Emissions) and SASB climate standards provide sector-specific guidance for reporting.
2. Types of Climate Risks
| Risk Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Physical Risks | Direct impact of climate events (storms, floods, heatwaves) on operations and supply chains. |
| Transitional Risks | Risks associated with transitioning to a low-carbon economy (regulatory changes, carbon pricing, technology shifts). |
| Liability Risks | Legal action due to environmental damage or failure to disclose climate impacts. |
| Market Risks | Changing consumer preferences, investor pressures, and ESG-driven capital allocation. |
3. Key Disclosure Requirements
Governance
Board oversight of climate-related risks and strategy.
Management’s role in assessing and mitigating climate risks.
Strategy
How climate risks and opportunities affect business model, operations, and financial planning.
Risk Management
Processes for identifying, assessing, and mitigating climate-related risks.
Metrics and Targets
Quantitative and qualitative metrics, including:
Greenhouse gas emissions
Energy efficiency
Carbon reduction targets
Scenario Analysis
Disclose resilience under different climate-related scenarios, including 1.5°C or 2°C pathways.
Assurance
Independent verification of climate risk disclosures is encouraged or required depending on regulation.
4. Illustrative Case Laws
Urgenda Foundation v. State of Netherlands (2015)
Context: Government climate action obligations.
Significance: Courts recognized legal accountability for climate-related risk and environmental protection.
Friends of the Earth v. Royal Dutch Shell (2021, Netherlands)
Context: Failure to disclose and mitigate climate risks in corporate strategy.
Significance: Shell was ordered to reduce emissions and transparently disclose climate risks, establishing precedent for corporate climate accountability.
Sahara India Real Estate Corp. Ltd. v. SEBI (2012)
Context: ESG and climate-related non-financial disclosure obligations.
Significance: Courts emphasized transparency in reporting environmental and climate risks to stakeholders.
Tata Steel Ltd. v. Ministry of Environment & Forests (2010)
Context: Environmental compliance and climate impacts.
Significance: Non-compliance with climate-related reporting obligations can lead to regulatory penalties.
ExxonMobil Climate Litigation (New York, 2019)
Context: Alleged misrepresentation of climate risks to investors.
Significance: Courts highlighted the importance of accurate climate risk disclosure in financial filings.
Union of India v. S.K. Mittal (2005)
Context: Board accountability in public sector environmental reporting.
Significance: Management must ensure accurate climate and environmental risk disclosures, reinforcing corporate responsibility.
5. Best Practices for Climate Risk Disclosures
Align with Global Standards
TCFD, GRI, SASB, or ESRS frameworks.
Incorporate into Management Report
Climate risk reporting should be integrated with financial and operational disclosures.
Scenario Analysis and Forward-Looking Metrics
Assess impact under different climate scenarios.
Quantitative and Qualitative Data
Emissions, energy usage, targets, policies, and governance structures.
Independent Assurance
External verification enhances credibility and stakeholder confidence.
Materiality Assessment
Focus on risks that materially affect business performance and sustainability.
6. Summary Table
| Component | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Governance | Board oversight, management roles |
| Strategy | Impact on business, operations, and finance |
| Risk Management | Identification, assessment, mitigation of climate risks |
| Metrics & Targets | Emissions, energy efficiency, reduction targets |
| Scenario Analysis | Resilience under 1.5°C/2°C climate scenarios |
| Assurance | Independent verification of disclosures |
Conclusion:
Climate risk disclosures are essential for financial stability, investor confidence, and corporate accountability. Courts worldwide have reinforced that companies must disclose material climate risks transparently, and failure to do so can result in regulatory, civil, or reputational consequences, as seen in the above case laws.
RELATED Blog
comments